I hired a car from Scott at Islaycarhire.com in February 2009 for 3 days. I'd used this company in March 08 as well.

I was met at the airport by Scott with the car I requested and was on my way in less than 5 minutes.

Nothing was too much trouble and I simply dropped the keys off just before boarding my flight home.

Great service and always a prompt reply to any enquiries you may have.

I would definately recommend you check them out as friendly and efficient service like this doesn't happen ofetn in my experience..