We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox. Mac: Safari.

Goa

Today's Poll
What are your plans for the four-day Diamond Jubilee weekend (2-5 June 2012)?
Free Newsletter

Interested in Goa?

We'll send you updates with the latest deals, reviews and articles for Goa each week.

Goa Forum: Cultural question about widows

Which Goa hotels are on sale?
See hotels
Bristol...
posts: 62
reviews: 24
 Cultural question about widows 

Can anyone explain please why there appears to be a stigma attached to being a widow in India?

I like reading the paper while here in Goa and the Times of India carried an article recently about Oprah Winfrey's visit and some comments she made at the Jaipur Literary Festival. She made a comment about how she didin't understand why widows are treated badly when their only 'crime' was their husband had died.

As a visitor from the West, where being a widow does not carry any stigma at all, can someone please explain why it is different in India?

10 replies
Kolkata...
posts: 5,888
reviews: 11
1. Re: Cultural question about widows
Destination Expert   What's this?
for Kolkata (Calcutta), Darjeeling

Hi Cheryl,

Widows have been treated badly in India since ancient times and were considered as unlucky as their husbands had died. Until the early 1900's, there was a pratice of "sati" which was the widow had to throw herself into the burning pyre of her husband as her life was not worth living. It was a cruel tradition, banned by the British and finally put to a stop by Raja Ramohan Roy and other intellectuals who had to fight against society.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sati_%28practice%29

Widows still have a stigmata attached to them in many Indian villages, are made to stay alone, head shaven, wear only white sarees and eat only vegetarian food (not even onions). In their old age, they were supposed to move to Varanasi and patiently await their death. Deepa Mehta made a film about the plight of widows, you should see it to get a better understanding.

wsws.org/articles/2006/may2006/wate-m15.shtml

Edited: 28 January 2012, 7:52
Birmingham...
posts: 528
reviews: 11
2. Re: Cultural question about widows

Thanks Kolkata very interesting read and I never knew any of that

London...
posts: 2,045
3. Re: Cultural question about widows
Destination Expert   What's this?
for Goa

See ya never to old to learn ;-)

Thanks Brave1 for today's history lesson. I did know that years ago women used to throw themselves on the fire, but is this just unique to Hindu's ?

Kolkata...
posts: 5,888
reviews: 11
4. Re: Cultural question about widows
Destination Expert   What's this?
for Kolkata (Calcutta), Darjeeling

Hi Kal,

Yes it was a hindu tradition right from the ancient times. The Rajput ladies of Rajasthan used to take pride in it, those who did were considered martyrs and people used to sing songs in their honour.

Birmingham...
posts: 528
reviews: 11
5. Re: Cultural question about widows

Thanks to Kal for not pointing out I am losing my marbles and got Brave's name wrong (was up very early trying to get everything ready to pack) even though I am old lol ;0)

Apologies Brave for referring to you as an area and not your user name.

Edited: 28 January 2012, 11:05
Kolkata...
posts: 5,888
reviews: 11
6. Re: Cultural question about widows
Destination Expert   What's this?
for Kolkata (Calcutta), Darjeeling

No problems, dwyall. :-)

wolverhampton
posts: 585
reviews: 3
7. Re: Cultural question about widows

True what they say you learn something new everyday,Thanks for that Brave1.

Bristol...
posts: 62
reviews: 24
8. Re: Cultural question about widows

Thanks all for the replies, very interesting but also very sad for the poor widows. As if it wasn't bad enough to lose a loved one, they are treated so badly. I struggle to understand how other family members, fathers, brothers, sons, daughters etc can treat their mothers and sisters in this way.

Is the stigma still present in modern day India?

Is it Hindu - or does it occur in all religions in India?

Are modern empowered women doing anything to change attitudes?

LIVERPOOL
posts: 5,281
reviews: 11
9. Re: Cultural question about widows

Very interesting article brave1.

Perth...
posts: 3,105
reviews: 39
10. Re: Cultural question about widows

With my very limited knowledge, yes in many rural parts of India widows are still treated badly and often forced to leave their homes From what I understand in those sorts of environments when a daughter marries she goes to live with her new husbands family and in the same way when a son marries his new wife comes to live with his parents. Therefore it can be that the son, not the daughter, puts his mother out into the street.

There are now a few wonderful organisations who assist widows, give them shelter and teach them skills to enable them to support themselves in a simple way. I had read about this before this trip and we were fortunate to come across a group of these ladies on one of our journeys who were on an outing and the lady who was the tour leader explained it all to us. Each of them had a different coloured beautiful sari and, although very shy, were happy to be photographed with me. I think you could possibly google "widows in India and perhaps some of these organisation will pop up. Thank goodness these organisations exist even though they are still very small.

Edited: 29 January 2012, 10:41
Reply to: Cultural question about widows
Get notified by e-mail when a reply is posted
Preview
See all sites
Cruise Critic

The ultimate cruise resource: cruise reviews, deals, news and advice.

SeatGuru

The world's most comprehensive source for airline seats, airline info, & in-flight amenities.

Family Vacation Critic

The best family holidays start here.

Best beach houses of 2012 »