This was our first trip back to Isla in several years and our second stay with Bucaneros. We got a small budget room for two again because when we booked in September the larger rooms were all taken. Since we were only there for 2 nites, this wasn't too much of an inconvenience, any longer stay you would probably be happier with a larger room with chairs and more room to move around. Even so, for 2 nites Christmas week, we paid well under a hundred bucks for a clean air-conditioned room, ceiling fan, Mexican cable TV, good bathroom with hot shower, free drinking water dispensed right outside the door. Try that in Cancun or Playa del Carmen, can't beat the value. Isla is a magnet that draws you back, and we wanted to savor it for a couple days of our 12 day holiday.
One new feature was that you could prepay with credit card and get the welcome drink and free continental breakfast deal, whereas before you had to actually do a bank transfer to get the prepay bonus, which was too much of a hassle to mess with. So we got our welcome drinks. The continental breakfast is handy - very good coffee, delicious freshly squeezed OJ, 3 pieces of toast with jam. They did have a large daily breakfast buffet if you're really famished.
Again, we were well satisfied with the hotel, restaurant and housekeeping staff. Good privacy and security. We were saving our diving for Cozumel this trip, but met a number of divers staying there, as it's handy to a couple of shops and a bargain.
Bucaneros is on the main pedestrian shopping street and is in the center of the night-time restaurant and bar scene, which we consider handy. Sorry to hear about the noise problem of an earlier reviewer, but we never noticed it. Around 9 or 10 pm, they pretty much roll up the street as far as the shopping activity goes, and it gets peaceful enough. Isla is much smaller than Cozumel, and the main beach areas are just a short pleasant stroll away from the hotel.
We recommend Bucaneros for anyone who doesn't require a pool or need to be on the beach, but wants to explore and enjoy the ambience and shopping on Isla. Did I mention that the price-value is unbeatable.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC