We ended up staying here by chance during the March break this year. Let us start by saying we tend to be more independent travellers, and this was thef irst time we actually did an entire week's worth of an all-inclusive type of vacation, so we obviously have no standard to compare to. However, we have visited other AI resorts on day trips, ( Palace, Iberostar, RUI,Sandals, etc) We had orginally booked our 1 BR timeshare at the Mayan Palace, ( (which was not AI) just outside of Playa Del Carmen, but were overwhelmed with the size and how busy the resort was , compared to how much smaller, quieter and peaceful it had been 5 years ago when we had last been there. We had booked the promo " timeshare" tour of HVR at the airport on our way in, and got a sunset cruise for 2 with lobster dinners for $64.00 US, which was a good deal . We had some problems getting there, as we were actually hijacked and taken to another similar named resort first... but we insisted on going to what we had booked and they eventually put us in a cab which brought us there. By then it was 11 AM and we were obviously late for our 9 AM breakfast meeting. The people at the resort who run the sales promotions were appalled at what had happened to us and refunded all the money we had paid, while still giving us the sunset cruise and dinner for free. Bonus! this gave us an excellent first impression of customer service, although it was probably just good business.- I think they were happy that we still showed up. Needless to say, we had breakfast, toured the resort, and found it to be the perfect kind of small, intimate resort that we prefer.
And that is the key to this place- it IS small, and you have to be able to amuse yourself, or you will definately not find it to your liking. Bring a book, your walkman, and if need be your computer and own DVD's to amuse yourself as there is nothing offered at the resort. There are no pool activities, no shows, no entertainment of any sort- for that you would have to either go in to Playa or Cancun itself. The service is laid back and very Mexican- nothing happens in a hurry, so if you are an "A" type it might not be to your liking unless you are trying to slow down the pace for a week. Everything was clean, and we thought it was well maintained overall.. We thought the room was nice, although a bit small ( we had a studio, and our window did open to the outside, although we did meet other poeople with inside rooms who did feel it was 'dungeonlike' ), but since they allowed us to move from the MP we felt that we should not be overly cirtical as they basically offered us what they had available.
We did have to purchase the AI plan, and felt that it was worth the money. However, I do agree with other traveller's comments that bit more variety in menus would have been appreciated. We found the overall quality of the food to be very good - they claimed it was gourmet, but for that distinction they have to work a bit harder( food & beverages/alchohol selection at RUI Palace RV and resorts of that qaulity still better by far, but then you also pay more, there ).The staff were always ready to try to honour any special request ( one morning we asked them to cook up some quaker oats we had brought with us, which they did). Unlike some other travellers here , we found the personnel to be very friendly and helpful.
I found it interesting that someone said they paid $ 10 for the van to take them to the beach club-we missed the shuttle as I was late coming back from a spa appointment, and I had to pay $ 25 US to get them to drive me one way ( my husband decided to stay by the pool up at the spa that day). Be warned that the shuttle only runs at specific times... both there and back. The beach is beautiful, but with the exception of about 2 small places everything else has been destroyed by recent hurricanes and not rebuilt, so there is really nothing to do there except swim & tan. There is small eating area, and I had no problem as they had my favorite lunch item of shrimp , so I have no complaints. My only reservation was the washrooms, which were out of commission- and had to be ' pail flushed'- they definately need to be attended to! Beware there are no change rooms on site that we could find.
My husband really enjoyed the salt water jacuussi pool and the pool upstairs by the dining room , although they could use more shade up there as it is sweltering during the day. I preferred the beach, although it was nice to come back and warm up in the salt water pool & heated chairs. after the beach which was cooler and very windy this year compared to previous years at this time.
The spa treatements I had were great, although pricewise they are about the same cost as here, so don't expect any bargains.( about $ 130 for an hour & half massage) Several people told me they went into town and found much cheapoer massages etc., but iIconfess i liked the ambiance at the spa itself, and I guess that is built into the price. Plus I could walk back to my room, or the pool, or wherever afterwards and continue relaxing, so for me it was worth it.
Overall, we feel we got our money's worth, and are already looking forward to coming again next year, although we will try to get a 1 BR room with a balcony rather than just a studio next time , as the studio room does become a bit cramped feeling after several days.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC