There are many great things about this resort, foremost being the stunning facilities and exceptional service. Every single staff member we encountered was super helpful and friendly. The grounds are immaculately kept, and everything is squeaky clean. Even the public bathrooms are to be admired!
The only things that weren't quite 5 star (in my humble opinion) were the food and the entertainment. Don't get me wrong, the food was good to very good and it was always beautifully presented, but I would not say that it was exceptional. Our favorite restaurants were Ginger and the new Thai restaurant (I can't remember its name). I had lobster several times during our stay and it was delicious (New Englanders may be disappointed with the size - we're spoilt!). The only thing is that the Lobster Pot restaurant doesn't serve anything but seafood, and so my husband had to sit there and watch me while I ate...at least he could drink!
Room service is wonderful in the morning (the only time we had it), and since we were upgraded to an ocean view room, it was so peaceful and relaxing to sit and eat on the patio.
Entertainment wise, the shows were a little hokey. The Michael Jackson show was good (if you like his music), and the fire show was good too - I actually liked it mostly because we got to meet other guests and chat with them (they do the show at the pool and seat you in groups for dinner). We didn't get to see the circus show - we were too exhausted from the tour we went on (see my review of Edventures - awesome!)
The daily activities we really enjoyed were the dance classes and making guacamole. I would have loved to do the kitchen tour and some others (like the cocktail class), but we missed some and others seemed to be canceled. (I must say that the entertainment staff are very nice and are a lot of fun.)
The main pool at the Valentin Maya is stunning and a wonderful place to hang out. The beach was always warm but breezy (which was nice - not too hot). The waves are moderate to quite big...it's definitely not 'like a swimming pool'! We split our time between the beach and pool which was perfect.
All in all we had a wonderful vacation. It's a great place to go if your main objective is to relax. If you want to do more than that, be prepared to spend quite a bit of money. No snorkeling trips, sunset cruises or other activities are included (as they were at the other all-inclusive we stayed at) and transportation from and to the airport is on your dime (we used prisma transfers, booked through [--], who were really good). Trips to Playa del Carmen cost $15 round trip p.p. but at least six people need to sign up from the hotel (on the day we wanted to go, no one else signed up). A cab will cost about $44 round trip.
Also, be prepared to tip...from what we understand, most service staff in Mexico get paid a very measly wage, and we felt bad not tipping. Over the course of a week, we probably spent $120 on this.
One last piece of advice, make sure you bring extra sun block - unless you are already well tanned, you WILL need a high SPF - take it from sunburned me (and I used SPF 40)! It's expensive to buy in the gift shop. Also, and this one's for the ladies... bring conditioner! After a day at the beach, the 'conditioning shampoo' provided by the resort left my hair looking like a rat's nest! (So I bought a small bottle at the gift shop for $5.50)
I hope this helps you make a more informed decision about your precious vacation. The candid information on Tripadvisor has been very valuable to me...hopefully I have 'paid it forward'.

914 Reviews
380 Reviews
3 Reviews
16 Reviews




Value
Location (e.g., convenience, views)
Service




