We decided to stay here over the Easter break and having read reviews for both the Holiday Inn and Ramada Jarvis , we settled for Holiday Inn.
Check in was a slow process and am not sure if they have a staff shortage as was only one person behind the counter and we saw no attempts by her to try and call for someone else to help out.
We were given a first floor standard room (we had booked a standard room) and when we entered the room , we got this funny whistling noise as already described by someone in an earlier review. I noticed that the main double glazing window was left open and so the noise was as a result of the wind trapped in the secondary glazing and main external window. The external window was so old and jammed and I nearly cut myself trying to close it - seems the windows have not been repaired for a while let alone replaced.
The room was clean and bathroom looked like it had not been renovated but was clean. We noticed the bathroom really steamed up after a shower and as such no extractor fans while there is a note to keep the bathroom door close to avoid the fire alarm to go off - so had to wait for the bathroom on 'un steam' before I could shave!!
The soaps dispensers in the bathroom were empty and not filled - luckily we brought our own soaps - I know the manager will say contact reception but we just were not in the mood to get disrupted - little did we know what we were in for....
After we settled into our room my better half went for a shower while I took a nap, after her shower the bathroom door handle came off completely basically locking her in the bathroom. She had to really bang the door to wake me up - this was not a good start especially when she was 8 moths pregnant!
we also noticed that the air-conditioning did not work properly. You had to insert you room key card to activate the temperature control and as it was warm I turned the room temperature to 16 degree and after 5 mins the whole unit turned off. Turned it back on again it turned off after 5 minutes. I tried raising the temperature control to 25 degrees and again after 5 minutes it would turn off - as it it was controlled centrally and not by room. In the end we had to open the windows.
We later complained at the reception when we popped down and again had to wait a while before someone could see us. Initially the lady behind the reception said she would get maintenance to sort the problems out in the room as she had a look of surprise when I explained about the aircon. No sooner had she said this and I turned round, she changed her mind and asked me if we would be happy to move rooms instead and I did say maybe we would as opposed to have workmen in our room I what was supposed to be a short break in Brighton!
The new room allocated to us was 5 doors away in the same floor and , the layout of this room was similar with suttle changes like it had just one chair while the other room had 2 chair sofas which were more comfortable. The lightening in the bathroom was very dim and some mould could be seen too. The aircon again was not working, it kept turning off every 5 mins irrespective of the temperature set and we resorted to opening the window as calling the reception and then having some person knock on our door was not what we had in mind for a peaceful stay.
We had dinner at main restaurant behind the main reception at the ground floor and dinner was buffet style and we were thoroughly disappointed that despite calling the restaurant earlier and being assured there was a vegetarian choice there was hardly potatoes and salad for us vegetarians. To make matters worse none of the food was labelled and my wife took a salad which had pork before she suspected and asked a waiter who confirmed - this was rather disappointing especially in a place where they charge £5 for a bottle of drinking water!
Breakfast was modest and selection was not amazing but what you would expect. That evening i.e on our second day, we had barely unpacked in our new room less than 24 hours ago previous day and approx 5:30 PM, we began to hear loud music coming from somewhere. Initially we turned the TV down but noise kept coming and became louder and we could feel the vibrations from the floor of the room.
Upon contacting the reception and asking to speak to guest relations , the lady apologised and told us the reason we were given the first floor was because my wife was pregnant and I argued what difference that made as we used the lift anyway irrespective of which floor we would have been - duh?
When we came down to the reception to make a formal complaint - again a long wait before someone could see to us and when complaining that this stay of ours was turning out to be some joke , we were Yes - yet again we offered to change rooms to a different floor and yes for the 3rd time in 2 days - we packed again! This was getting tiring and more like a camp as opposed to a break!
The new room we were given as an executive room - we were struggling to notice what was so executive about it and as clearly pointed out by an earlier review - it included bath robes (£30 if you wished to keep them) , 1 kitkat and a small orange drink!
I guess this is what the hotel felt was adequate to 'compensate' us for changing rooms 3 times and my wife being heavily pregnant! . Funny enough in the executive room the aircon worked fine and never kept turning off but the main external windown would not close and so we kept hearing the whistling sound throughout the night - so Mr manager, when reading this review please note that its not only seafront rooms but 3 of the rooms we used had wondows which could hardly shut - this surely is a security issue as well?
The car park as mentioned by many is so small with boxes for each car that would make it impossible to open the door with a car next t it - not sure why the hotel is not addressing this and re-drawing the allocated spaces as just not practical. all the large spaces in the car park are reserved for residents who stay above the hotel so there you go!
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC
Would I recommend this hotel to my best friend?
Probably not
I recommend this hotel for:
Young Singles, A romantic getaway, Girlfriend getaway, Families with Small Children, Families with Teenagers, tourists
I do not recommend this hotel for:
An Amazing Honeymoon, A romantic getaway, People with disabilities, Older Travellers
I selected this hotel as a top choice for:
Beach / Sun, Museums / Cultural / Historical sites, Theme / Amusement park, Other
Management Response
BHTSF_GM, General Manager
(Management representative)
30 Apr 2008
Thank you for putting your comments onto this website and assure you that all feedback is used as our ongoing Customer Service Improvement Programme.
All bedrooms within the hotel have undergone a £3.5m refurbishment programme and is disappointing to read your comments regarding the room. From your feedback I have ask the maintenance team to carry out a full audit on all the bedrooms on the 1st floor and where possible action will be taken.
We have chosen to use soap dispensers within the hotel as part of our commitment to the environment and reducing unnecessary waste. One downside to these is the mechanism within them to notify that they require change and occasionally they fail. We always have a duty manager on site to assist with any requests.
Since your stay we have re-launched our a la carte menu where there are now more than 10 vegetarian main courses available. I assure you we do not charge £5 for a bottle of water.
All our Executive rooms are on the 4th floor so security issue is not a problem but am disappointed that you found the window issues.
Car Parking throughout Brighton is limited and we have where possible enlarged spaces in the last year causing reduced spaces available. Where pillars, supporting the hotel are in the way, this has not been possible. The flats above the hotel have separate spaces from the hotel and unfortunately it is not possible to move these.
We have recently been awarded a Guest Satisfaction Award for out continual improvement to ensuring full guest satisfaction and I am saddened to here your feedback. Should you wish to contact me directly I am happy to speak to you regarding your concerns.
This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of TripAdvisor LLC