We went to El Crosto last night for my birthday dinner, following recommendations here on TripAdvisor. It was a wednesday night and except for one other table we had the place to ourselves. It is a little hard to find, around a corner and with only a small sign, and inside is one little room lined with pigs and vodka bottles.
There is no menu (he will just tell you what is being served), and unless you speak Catalan, French or Spanish it is best to just have him 'recomanar' (recommend). We did this because we only speak english.
I can guarantee though that whatever you eat will be wonderful! My husband and I had an apple and mushroom salad and the pasta for starters, The 'grill' (essentially steak and chips, but amazing) and the duck on onions (well, I think that was what it was! It was good!), and for dessert we shared a plate of chocolate pieces wrapped in parcels, deep fried and dipped in coulis...... O.M.G.!
When he found out it was my birthday he also brought out chocolate truffles (one with a candle in the top) and sang me happy birthday in Catalan :-) He was a wonderful, funny and very entertaining host.
We didn't ask for prices along the way (too hard because we only speak english) With bread, meats and olives to start, all that I have mentioned, and a bottle of wine our bill was €60.... amazing value!!
Don't hesitate, if you are in Andorra la Vella just spoil yourself and go there - you wont regret it!!
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC