We HAD to go to this place, since Jimmy Buffet is such a Key West icon. I planned to order a classic menu...the Cheeseburger in Paradise and Margarita! I mean, come on...I'm in Key, I have to do it. Well, the burger was tasty! The margarita wasn't as good or as strong as I had hoped for. Just ok. Pretty pricey so I was disappointed with that. (I'd say go for a cold beer instead!) The rest of my family ALL ordered the FISH AND CHIPS and loved them! One person has become the "fish official" and still to this day says this was the best he's had. That's a pretty tall order, so I guess it was good! It's a fun place; cute atmosphere; very nice and friendly workers! The gift shop next door is cute, but expensive. I still say, if you go to Key you have to go here, at least for a cocktail...so go!
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC
28 June 2012
Thanks for coming in, Monica D! We are thrilled that everyone had a good time with us! Also, what an honor that the "fish official" thinks we are the best! FINtastic! Your comments about the drinks will be shared with the team as well. Look forward to having you back!
Report response as inappropriate
- Margaritaville Management Team
This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of TripAdvisor LLC