This was one of my favorites on the island. If you're lucky enough to snag a patio table for your meal, consider yourself lucky. The patio was always full during our trip. The menu is large and offers eveything from salads to pizza to steak and pasta. There's even a kids menu. Portions are large and prices were about average for the island. The restaurant is connected to a hotel, so if you weren't able to snag a patio seat for you meal, you can always snag a rocking chair on the hotel's front porch after your meal. It's a great people watching spot.
If you own or manage Goodfellows, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.