My daughter and I stayed at the Dew Drop Inn for a week in August 2008, and we're already booked to go back for Thanksgiving!
The location is great, as it's directly across the street from the only grocery store in town.
We had an upstairs room, all of which have private balconies, while the first floor rooms all had patios.
We also had a small fridge and microwave, which was really nice, and helped cut down a lot on the expense of eating out!
Our room was very large, and VERY clean! The housekeeping here was amazing! A couple mornings we went to eat breakfast, only to have to return afterward to retreive a forgotten something or other, and to our surprise, the room had already been cleaned!
We never heard any noise from any of the other rooms. As a matter of fact, if we hadn't seen the cars in the parking lot each evening, I would have sworn we were the only ones there! I slept so well there, I hated to leave!
Very quiet, very peaceful, very comfy, all around a wonderful stay!
Judging strictly by the outside looks of the other motels in town, the Dew Drop Inn looked to be the nicest/newest.
Also, I read that they now have a Bella Suite, in honor of the Twilight books. Don't know if this was a one time thing for Stephenie Meyer's Day on September 13th, but for fans of the books, it might be worth checking out!