This was a highlight of our 3 week trip west. We arrived early, the staff was helpful and personable. They were full of suggestions and knowledgeable and seemed to take pride in their hotel. The rooms' doors are left open before arrival, and guests are encouraged to "tour" the rooms and suites. We wandered the halls, looking at the memorabilia, we sat in the lobby, had a beer in the saloon. The whole place is like a museum. I'm not an expert on antiques, I'm not sure if everything in the hotel was a true period piece, but it suited my wife and I just fine. We stayed in the "Hole in the Wall" room, it was comfortable (had a bathtub, which just seemed to lend to the whole experience of old-timeyness) and quiet - the creek alongside the room lulled us to sleep. Did not come for the wireless internet - but it worked quite well in the library (impressive) down the hall. Be sure you arrive here early so you can look around the place, poke your head in all the rooms, and just soak in the atmosphere. Last but not least, the price was cheaper than some of the chain motels up by the highway.

We stayed here on the way from Custer State Park to the east enterance to Yellowstone. The hotel, bar and restaurant actually exceeded the positive reviews. We truly felt as if we stepped back in time. We stayed in the 2 bedroom Butch Cassiday and Sundance Kid suite which is great for families. The beds were comfortable and the room had a working old fashion radio. We had great steaks at the restaurant and enjoyed drinks at the saloon beforehand where the bartender showed us the bullet holes in the ceiling and wall. Although I am not a big western movie or book fan, I read The Virginian based upon comments of an earlier reviewer and really recommend that you read this great book before your visit - the author lived at the hotel for a period of 3 years while writing the book. This place is a hidden gem and I hope I am able to return.

The owners of this hotel truly love what they do, and it shows. We were greeted by one of them, who explained that her husband is the author of Zoo Books for kids. She proceeded to take the kids by hand and let them pick out books to take home. That set the tone.

The building itself has been beautifully restored. The lobby has walls full of old photos of the place and photos of famous people who have stayed there over the years. We felt like we were staying in a museum, but one where we were made to feel welcome at every turn. It was clean and quiet, and lots of extras were provided (like coffee/tea/cookies at all hours). We stayed in the Bordello Suite, and had a TON of room (3 queen size beds each in separate bedroom). They also have a library and free WiFi. Parking is on the street (not a problem, as there was plenty of parking right across the street).

Both historic and restful. Part hotel and museum. Rooms range from single bed and small TV with bathroom/shower across the hallway to plush suites/rooms. Great staff and restaurant. (The Buffalo steaks were tremendous!) They even have a library. Bar stays open as late as the crowd allows. Highly recommended.