The Inn is a good location, walking distance from the ferry (a couple blocks so not with big luggage) but what we didn't know was the room we booked (the Hideaway) was another block or so further away from the Inn. When we got to the room, that wasn't a problem, it was very nice, skylights, new, great bathroom and very quiet. However, when we checked in we didn't get offered the same "service" as other guests who checked in to stay at the main Inn, even though the room cost just as much (like being told about parking, games, cookies in the afternoon, continental b-fast, etc. We felt like 3rd class citizens). We then discovered in our room though that the Hideaway came with free b-fast at this great cafe/diner across the street that was way better than continental b-fast. So as long as you know the above, its great. I would encourage the Inn to disclose the fact that the Hideaway is not attached to the hotel and that guests can still use the hotel (and sister hotel, the Friday Harbor Inn) amenities.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC