We stayed in Room 21 (Justene at the top) at the Andreas Hotel in Oct. 2007. It is a very charming place within the old city walls. The room was reasonable in size, cleanliness and comfort, but the bathroom was a tight fit. The bath was insuite, which is not always the case at Andreas. Open windows provided good ventilation and the air conditioning took care of the hot days. The view of the city outside our windows was terrific. The Andreas is located within the old walls, so you can walk to all attractions, restaurants and shopping. Breakfast was good, although it lacked any meats or hot plates. I think you can request eggs cooked to order. The terrace was a very pleasant place to eat or have wine later. The staff was extremely friendly and helpful. The airline lost our luggage for nearly 3 days and the staff was constantly on the phone to track it down and get it brought from Gatwick to Rhodes airport. The price for the room was reasonable, but does not include breakfast.

A couple of points to consider. The top room (#21) has a difficult staircase to go up and down without elevator service. With luggage you have to be fairly agile. This room is not suitable for elderly with heavy luggage. Otherwise it has the best view and conveniences. The hotel can set up transfers from the ferry port and airport for a reasonable rate (8 euro from ferry port one-way) that take you almost to the hotel door. Normal taxis stop outside the walls and you have to drag luggage a distance over unbearably rough streets. We had to drive a rental car into the inner city once and the narrow roads and parked cars/motorcycles made it a difficult job. The airport is a significant distance away and taxi service is around 20 euro.

We enoyed our stay at the Andreas and were happy we chose it.

I booked room 16 in hotel Andreas for the 2 nights after asking advice from Tripadvisor contributors. Getting from St Johns Gate (where the taxi dropped us ) was a mini ordeal ; over cobbles in blazing heat with wheeled suitcases, but was worth it for the view. Our reception was excellent, people were just checking out of our room when we arrived, we were offered a courtesy drink on the terrace and got our breath back. Our room was available as soon as possible and to be fair we were there before midday. The room was as I expected 2 single beds 'downstairs' and a double on a mezzanine floor (somewhat like the traditional Greek marriage bed). The toilet/shower was tiny but adequate and clean. Beds clean and comfortable. Although the room technically sleeps 4 I wouldn't want to share it with 3 others for a prolonged period as there is not much space. It was ideal for 3 of us for 2 nights. I also noticed through open doors that some other rooms were quite small so you should check what you are booking suits your needs. Also there was a communal fridge available, a bonus when temperature are over 30 degrees. Breakfast was perfect for a mere 6 euro each. As one of my companions commented she could happily eat breakfast there for the rest of her life! All in all good value and pleasant and helpful service. Sorry I didn't take photos but the hotel's website photos are honest.

Nice hotel. It was cheap, 60 euros a night. For this price, however, I had the smallest view I've ever stayed in. Me and my girlfriend had to dance around each other whilst in the one narrow area of the room which had standing space. The rest of the room was taken up by a huge, very comfortable bed. It's a nice place if you are just going to sleep and want lots of natural light. If you want a room to lounge around in, this is not the place. Still, the hotel was very charming, the room romantic, and the breakfast superb. Thus the 4 rating. Though 3.5 is probably more appropriate.

Three of us shared a triple room at Andreas and we loved the place despite the closet sized bathroom with its concertina vinyl door and the gymnastics required to have a shower without flooding the toilet. Otherwise the room was great - two singles downstairs and a loft with a double.
As a group including mature travellers, we found having to carry luggage up a flight of stairs a challenge but we got help which was greatly appreciated. Andreas is friendly, helpful and welcoming and the breakfast was ideal. It is budget priced but behaves better than most higher order hotels. I would happily stay there again and we really appreciated having Anna meet us at the airport with our driver and get us into the maze that is the Old City of Rhodes. The cost of this service was only slightly more than a regular taxi and Annna's style of meet and greet was worth every penny. Good luck to anyone trying to find Hotel Andreas without this service.