We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox. Mac: Safari.

Shelter Island

Free Newsletter

Interested in Shelter Island?

We'll send you updates with the latest deals, reviews and articles for Shelter Island each week.

Explore the world! TripAdvisor has reviews and information on over 400,000 locations, including:
Hotels

Explore other Shelter Island resources:

Visiting Shelter Island, NY


Add Videos
Add Photos
Free Shelter Island Guide

Get your quick guide to the top hotels, restaurants and things to do.

Shelter Island
Click map pins for more information.
view map of Shelter Island
Holiday rentals are ideal for your longer stay.
Spend time in Shelter Island
Holiday rentals are ideal for your longer stay.
Find a rental»
Other Destinations
Popular Hamptons Destinations
Albany Hotels
Binghamton Hotels
Buffalo Hotels
Cooperstown Hotels
Jamestown
Lake Placid Holiday Rentals
New York City Holiday Rentals
Niagara Falls Hotels
Plattsburgh Hotels
Poughkeepsie Hotels
Saratoga Springs Hotels
Westchester County Hotels
Find Cheap Flights from San Francisco to New Haven

Traveller Advice on Shelter Island

8 Hotels & Accommodations

Find out more on these hotels
Find out more on these B&Bs
Hotel Quick Search – Find hotels travellers trust
dd/mm/yyyy dd/mm/yyyy
Go to Shelter Island Hotels & Accommodations

2 Things to Do

View all Shelter Island attractions
Go to Shelter Island Things to Do

16 Restaurants

View all Shelter Island restaurants

Before You Go

  • Traveller Articles – Advice from real travellers
View all Traveller Articles on Shelter Island
Free Shelter Island Guide

Get your quick guide to the top hotels, restaurants and things to do.

Go to Shelter Island Before You Go

Weather

 | 
Monthly Averages
Month
High
Low
Precip
Dec
42°F 5°C
24°F -4°C
2 in 6 cm
Jan
35°F 1°C
19°F -7°C
2 in 5 cm
Feb
38°F 3°C
21°F -6°C
2 in 5 cm
Mar
43°F 6°C
27°F -2°C
3 in 7 cm
Apr
54°F 12°C
35°F 1°C
3 in 7 cm
May
63°F 17°C
43°F 6°C
3 in 7 cm
Extended Forecast
Tuesday
29 Dec
Hi:
29°F -1°C
Lo:
16°F -8°C
Wednesday
30 Dec
Hi:
31°F 0°C
Lo:
22°F -5°C
Thursday
31 Dec
Hi:
36°F 2°C
Lo:
34°F 1°C
More weather for Shelter Island
Powered by
Weather Underground

Reviews you can trust

“Lively and Tasty”

Vine Street Cafe

4 of 5 stars
Btenneson
Seattle
16 Nov 2009

3 generations visited during slack season (?!) on a Saturday-Vine Street was overflowing with a noisy and pleasant crowd (my guess is many were from off-island). Innovative salads with organic produce...more

“Fun and worth the visit”

Planet Bliss Incorporated

4 of 5 stars
Btenneson
Seattle
13 Nov 2009

3 generations of family on a November night. Ecclectic and somewhat organic mix of tasty food. Chinese Food on the special was very worthwhile, tandouri chicken, burgers, and more. Young and fun...more

“One of our absolute favorite restaurants on Shelter Island”

Vine Street Cafe

5 of 5 stars
WaterDance09
New York City
11 Oct 2009

Atmosphere is warm, cozy, and inviting. Never have had a bad meal there. Cuisine is an elegant mix of several styles, resulting in some lovely unique dishes. A must eat! more

See all Shelter Island reviews

Shelter Island Forum

Ask a Question or Browse the Discussions
Hamptons Day Trip 10 November 2009, 2 replies
weather over xmas 02 November 2009, 1 reply
Day trip to the Hamptons? 27 August 2009, no replies
Hamptons for two days 20 August 2009, 2 replies
need help on Best way to get to Shelter Island 17 August 2009, no replies
Shelter Island Hideaway - Absolutely Beautiful- Peaceful 23 November 2009, 2 replies
Hamptons beach from NYC using public transportations 11 August 2009, 1 reply
Day trip to beach 27 July 2009, 4 replies
Hampton Bays Have never been ... 27 July 2009, 1 reply
What town to stay in the Hamptons for Families? 10 August 2009, 2 replies
View all discussions
Search the Shelter Island Forum
Post a new Shelter Island topic

Are You a Shelter Island Tourism Organisation?