Brotherhood of Thieves is a Nantucket institution offering the best burgers in town along with other traditional pub fare.  The name comes from a nineteenth century reference to those in the slave trade on Nantucket.  Brotherhood Sign

 

Downstairs you'll find a traditional dark pub atmosphere, and upstairs a decor in a softer palette of pale greens and blues along with many private dining rooms.  There's always a wait at the Brotherhood, but the food and friendly service makes it all well worth the trouble. The upstairs bar is fun and lively, while the patio bar is pleasant during good weather.