A friend and I stayed in room 307 at the Island Inn for a week in March 2013.
I'll start with the good stuff:
We reserved through iTrip, which was a pleasant experience. The room pictures were fairly accurate...kitchen is very basic, as is the bathroom. The fridge, cooking area, sink, bathroom, sheets were all clean and in good order when we arrived.
Two beach chairs and an umbrella, plus 2 beach towels, were provided with the rental. They provide some dish soap, sponges, towels (paper and cloth) garbage bags and TP to get you started. The hotel has 2 volleyball courts in the sand, a pool, and gass grills for customer use. Coffee/tea is available in the lobby all the time, as is a computer with internet access (wi-fi in the lobby, too). They also have paddle boards, but you cannot use them if you rent through anyone other than the hotel office.
And now for the rest:
They key we originally picked up at a lock box didn't work. A hotel maintenance man saw us... more