We LOVED Anguilla, and will definitely be going back. Utopian Property Management made everything easy- they booked charters and day trips for us (you MUST sail out to Prickly Pear Island with the Chocolat crew- our favorite adventure on the trip), introduced us to locals and gave fantastic recommendations for restaurants, and made sure everything was perfect for our stay.
The Fountain Residences are nice and relaxing. They are unfussy, and nicely decorated. The beds are VERY comfortable, and the showers are spacious. Shoal Bay East is probably the BEST beach, and place to stay, on the island. We like avoiding hotel and resort crowds, so the Fountain was the perfect size and collection of amenities for us. They have WiFi and the pool area is uncrowded (as in, no one but us) and beautiful. We met some of the other condo owners who were in town, and they were super friendly and invited us for dinner- fresh caught Mahi Mahi.
Anguilla is much more sleepy and...