We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Review Highlights
A great local market

Wow, the selection of apples was tremendous as well as well as the homemade pie selections. Well... read more

Reviewed 1 week ago
Windermere, Florida
Best orchard, hands down!

This orchard is so unique. It’s not crowded, it had an incredible variety of different kinds of... read more

Reviewed 17 September 2018
Port Jefferson, New York
via mobile
Read all 9 reviews
All photos (7)
Full view
Traveller Overview
  • Excellent78%
  • Very good22%
  • Average0%
  • Poor0%
  • Terrible0%
1 week ago
“A great local market”
16 Sep 2018
“Best orchard, hands down! ”
Local Weather
Powered by Weather Underground
1346 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, NY 11976-2630
+1 631-537-2565
Reviews (9)
Filter reviews
9 results
Traveller rating
Traveller type
Time of year
See what travellers are saying:
Updating list...
Reviewed 1 week ago

Wow, the selection of apples was tremendous as well as well as the homemade pie selections. Well worth the stop when heading east or west on Montauk highway. We will be back.

Thank kwolling8
Reviewed 17 September 2018 via mobile

This orchard is so unique. It’s not crowded, it had an incredible variety of different kinds of apples, it’s reasonably priced and run by a family that truly cares and is passionate about the business. This is our third year going with a large group...More

Thank kseebe00
Reviewed 1 September 2018 via mobile

Great place to pick your own apples and pumpkins. The staff is very friendly and helpful. There is also a retail area by the parking lot. During the fall, there is plenty of traffic in & out of the vicinity.

Thank sushiguy79
Reviewed 31 October 2016

We went to this farm in late October because it was one of the few places left around the area which had any apples. Thinking we would just get the last few apples, we were prepared not to get many good ones. However, we got...More

1  Thank KCNY2000
Reviewed 25 September 2016 via mobile

A wonderful place to visit with big, small and big supply of pumpkins. Bags and bags of honey crisp and many other types of apples.

Thank Steve S
Reviewed 7 November 2015

This market had seasonal, local vegetables and fruit. It is clean and friendly. Also offered a variety of baked goods, locally made. The prices for fresh local broccoli and cauliflower were higher than the most upscale NYC places, but we expect the taste will be...More

Thank Peggy C
Reviewed 20 October 2015

Well, it's late in the apple picking season, but I discovered Milk Pail and they were one of the few farms not picked out! So I drove the 2 hours from Queens out to the Hamptons because the obligatory apple picking must occur each year!...More

Thank Annie M
Reviewed 6 January 2015

The Milk Pail is a real jewel in the Hamptons. They grow their own apples, make their own apple cider and then make fresh, incredibly delicious, not too sweet Apple Cider Donuts. They sell artisan cheese and some dairy products. Its like gourmet 7-11. Yu...More

Thank Shelby C
Reviewed 12 October 2014

Milk Pail has a few locations on the South Fork (the Hamptons); we visited the location that is open year round. Milk Pail has just-picked-this-morning apples, pears, tomatoes, etc. They also offer a carefully curated selection of locally cooked and/or bottled items (pies, jams, pickles)...More

Thank doglover4
View more reviews
Nearby HotelsSee all nearby hotels
Topping Rose House
146 reviews
2.30 miles away
Southampton Village Motel
100 reviews
3.07 miles away
33 reviews
3.08 miles away
Southampton Inn
328 reviews
3.96 miles away
Nearby RestaurantsSee all 18 nearby restaurants
Hampton Coffee Company Espresso Bar & Cafe
42 reviews
.86 miles away
Sabrosa Mexican Grill
19 reviews
.35 miles away
14 reviews
.58 miles away
Red Stix
5 reviews
.60 miles away
Nearby AttractionsSee all 6 nearby attractions
Parrish Art Museum
122 reviews
1.89 miles away
Children's Museum of The East End
35 reviews
3.16 miles away
Wolffer Estate Vineyard
177 reviews
3.57 miles away
Duck Walk Vineyards
98 reviews
1.99 miles away
Questions & Answers
Get quick answers from Milk Pail staff and past visitors.
Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page.
Posting guidelines