We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

It Shoulda Been You - CLOSED

Review Highlights
Plesant Surprise

We opted for this show as a lot of tickets for the more popular shows were not available. It was... read more

Reviewed 25 January 2016
Don't Miss This Show

What a surprise - the cast and writer (David Hyde Pierce) caught my eye and we decided to go during... read more

Reviewed 15 October 2015
Walnut Creek, California
Read all 143 reviews
All photos (18)
Full view
Traveller Overview
  • Excellent82%
  • Very good13%
  • Average3%
  • Poor0%
  • Terrible2%
25 Jan 2016
“Plesant Surprise”
15 Oct 2015
“Don't Miss This Show”
Emmy(R) and Tony Award(R) winner David Hyde Pierce directs an outstanding ensemble cast in IT SHOULDA BEEN YOU, the heartwarming and hilarious new musical comedy about what happens before happily ever after. Tony Award(R) winners Tyne Daly and...more
256 W 47th St, Brooks Atkinson Theater, New York City, NY 10036-1411
+1 877-250-2929
Improve This Listing
Reviews (143)
Filter reviews
141 results
Traveller rating
Traveller type
Time of year
See what travellers are saying:
Updating list...
1 - 10 of 141 reviews
Reviewed 25 January 2016

We opted for this show as a lot of tickets for the more popular shows were not available. It was highly rated so we gave it the chance. I enjoyed it more than i thought. I am not big on Broadway but this had me...More

Date of experience: April 2015
2  Thank 520courtneyb
Reviewed 15 October 2015

What a surprise - the cast and writer (David Hyde Pierce) caught my eye and we decided to go during our trip. I can't say how amazing Tyne Daly is - and the rest of the cast is superb. The story line was not at...More

Date of experience: May 2015
2  Thank msdawna
Reviewed 30 August 2015 via mobile

This play was very funny until the last 10 minutes when it has a strange twist,almost absurd. I thought it was me ,the play now seemed to have a political agenda .but when the elderly couple siting next to me got up and left the...More

Date of experience: August 2015
1  Thank NancePook
Reviewed 24 August 2015

FANTASTIC!!! What a fabulous show - we laughed and laughed! Really well scripted and acted - the show was recommended by a friend, and also glad I took their advice

Date of experience: July 2015
3  Thank planetseb
Reviewed 17 August 2015

This show is fun with surprising twists and turns. It's a happy, uplifting musical, and it was enjoyable to see Tine Daley. The storyline is quite contemporary and the twists concern partner choice. I don't want to say any more and spoil the fun. You...More

Date of experience: June 2015
2  Thank teach1NYC
Reviewed 10 August 2015 via mobile

If it goes on the road see it. Well worth the effort a wonderful afternoon ruined for future theater goers by luke warm reviews

Date of experience: August 2015
2  Thank Myro M
Reviewed 8 August 2015

What a fun and happy musical show this was! I enjoyed every second of it....the story, the music and the acting was superb! Tine Daley was amazing!

Date of experience: July 2015
2  Thank Karen1493
Reviewed 7 August 2015

It caught you f rom the first moment- great storyline - and a surprise half way thru- so much fun- great singing fun story

Date of experience: August 2015
2  Thank Sheela H
Reviewed 3 August 2015 via mobile

This is by far the best Broadway show we have ever seen, including all the big ones. It has absolutely no slow spots from the beginning to end. The cast is an all star list. You must see it before it closes.

Date of experience: August 2015
3  Thank mamalyn27407
Reviewed 1 August 2015

We did not read any reviews before booking this show and only booked it because Tyne Daly was starring in it! The show is fantastic from start to finish and we would have considered seeing it again if we had been in New York for...More

Date of experience: July 2015
2  Thank super95
View more reviews
Nearby HotelsSee all 500 nearby hotels
Paramount Hotel New York
5,875 reviews
.03 miles away
The Gallivant Times Square
2,368 reviews
.04 miles away
Hotel Edison Times Square
11,937 reviews
.05 miles away
Econo Lodge Times Square
1,356 reviews
.06 miles away
Nearby RestaurantsSee all 16,178 nearby restaurants
The Mean Fiddler
995 reviews
.03 miles away
Trattoria Trecolori
2,529 reviews
.01 miles away
Patzeria Perfect Pizza
1,151 reviews
.04 miles away
Carve Unique Sandwiches
1,055 reviews
.03 miles away
Nearby AttractionsSee all 4,874 nearby attractions
Longacre Theatre
146 reviews
.06 miles away
Richard Rodgers Theatre
261 reviews
.05 miles away
Imperial Theatre
353 reviews
.06 miles away
Barrymore Theatre
174 reviews
.03 miles away