We have stayed at the Hillcrest Guest House several times and will stay there again on our next trip. Clean and comfortable and conveniently located. The fridge is always well stocked. There is a lovely courtyard with beautiful plants and flowers.
We have loved staying with Phyllis at Hillcrest Guest House. We haven't been back since the hurricanes, but it looks like she has actually improved it. The only drawback is that awful hill you have to climb to get up there if you don't have a car.
In an attempt to save money, we decided to give this place a try. We entered to a n unclean space, rotted food in the refrigerator, a large gap under the entry door to let the critters in, a loud, filthy air conditioner in the window, a lumpy bed...you name it. Do not…
We stayed in the front suite. It has a great view of town and a good breeze to keep you cool at night. we never needed to use the air conditioner. Its located at the top of a big hill so walking back from town is a challenge but not to bad. We enjoyed the room very much.
We went with Hillcrest because of its proximity to downtown Cruz Bay, and the fact that our Orchid Suite has a kitchenette, in order to save money on food and parking fees. It is a five minute walk down (way down) to all the restaurants and bars in Cruz Bay, and an eight…
"Nice view, needs a little stove."
"If you can, you should go for the Front Suite."
"I imagine the upstairs rooms have better views, but more stairs!"
"There is apparently one rental that has a full kitchenette and might be good for those planning to cook in most of the time."
"I would ask for the lower apartment where the owner once lived, but ask if the kitchen sink works."