THE 10 BEST Hotels in Kelleys Island
Kelleys Island Hotels
and Places to StayEnter dates to find the best prices
Popular hotels in Kelleys Island right now
13 properties in Kelleys Island
Sort by:
- Best ValueProperties ranked using exclusive Tripadvisor data, including traveller ratings, confirmed availability from our partners, prices, booking popularity and location, as well as personal user preferences and recently viewed hotels.
- Traveller RankedHighest rated hotels on Tripadvisor, based on traveller reviews.
- Distance to city centreSee properties located closest to the centre first with confirmed availability for your dates from our partners
Payments made by partners impact the order of prices displayed. Room types may vary, learn more.
Enter dates to see prices
Kevin C
@kevincH9006PH
Reviewed on 22 May 2022
Epitome B&B
"Amazing room- spectacular lake views."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 13 places to stay in Kelleys Island
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
Bryant A
@Bryant A
Reviewed on 24 Sept 2017
Ideal bed & breakfast
"First time staying at a bed and breakfast as a young couple & we were extremely impressed with everything. Patty is most likely one of the sweetest people i've ever met travailing. she was very helpful with..."
Read all reviews
#2 Best Value of 13 places to stay in Kelleys Island
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
clemastersjr
@clemastersjr
Reviewed on 24 Sept 2016
Fantastic Getaway!
"A fantastic quiet getaway! Located right on the eastern shore with fantastic views, pier, dock, patio, and relaxing sounds of the lake from the room. Stacy the hostess is very friendly and informative. The rooms are..."
Read all reviews
#3 Best Value of 13 places to stay in Kelleys Island
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
Michele S
@Michele S
Reviewed on 11 Sept 2018
A Slice of Serenity
"If you are looking for a quiet, quaint and cozy place in a beautiful setting, this is the place to stay!
This was our first visit to The Eagles Nest and we really enjoyed our stay. The grounds are beautiful and a..."
Read all reviews
#4 Best Value of 13 places to stay in Kelleys Island
Enter dates to see prices
Jennifer M
@jennifermN5501FE
Reviewed on 29 Jul 2023
Fairly clean and well-maintained, but overpriced
"I’ve stayed here several times. Since this is the only non-BNB hotel on the island worth staying at, and it’s clean, I can’t really balk at the prices. That being said, there should be more included with the price..."
Read all reviews
#5 Best Value of 13 places to stay in Kelleys Island
Enter dates to see prices
Guesthouse
#6 Best Value of 13 places to stay in Kelleys Island
Enter dates to see prices
Camping/Caravan site
snpkelley
@snpkelley
Reviewed on 25 Jul 2021
Great family camping trip
"We loved the campground. Nearly all the sites are good and the campground was very family friendly. Everyone respected the quiet time rules. The only reason this is only a 4 star is because the bath houses are a..."
Read all reviews
#7 Best Value of 13 places to stay in Kelleys Island
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
Liz K
@Liz K
Reviewed on 29 Aug 2016
Me and my husband Frank stayed there in June, It was our first Bed and Breakfast, and first time to Kelleys Island.
"It was such a nice, clean beautiful place. Nice pool , close to downtown, and golf rental. The breakfast was amazing. Gracie was the one to be there, and she was so sweet and helpful on everything. We will be back..."
Read all reviews
#8 Best Value of 13 places to stay in Kelleys Island
Enter dates to see prices
Guesthouse
Omnigreen
@GreenPassion
Reviewed on 22 Aug 2018
A beautiful location.
"I've been bringing groups and traveling to Himmelblau for many years. It is one of my favorite lodging locations on Kelleys Island. It is peaceful and has a beautiful view of the Lake Erie sunrise. I love the..."
Read all reviews
#9 Best Value of 13 places to stay in Kelleys Island
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
brockey
@brockey
Reviewed on 12 Aug 2016
Very close to the ferry
"I really wanted to give this more than 3 but there is more things that should improve . Caroline the owner does a good job , she keeps up with having a clean home and nice breakfast ( fresh fruit, pastries , cereal..."
Read all reviews
#10 Best Value of 13 places to stay in Kelleys Island
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
lyncUP
@lyncUP
Reviewed on 13 Mar 2011
Best hotel room in Scotland!
"Stayed at Cameron House on the 11th February 2011 to celebrate my wifes birthday. The whisky room was simply awesome - thanks Tony.
What a great place, would highly recommend and look forward to returning."
Read all reviews
#11 Best Value of 13 places to stay in Kelleys Island
Enter dates to see prices
Inn
Gnocchi3
@Gnocchi3
Reviewed on 13 Jul 2013
If you have no other choice of accomodations...
"My wife & I go up to Kelleys all the time. Bunch of friends have boats at the marina and we used to stay on one of them, but they downsized so hence we had to look for other accomodations. Being last minute and the..."
Read all reviews
#12 Best Value of 13 places to stay in Kelleys Island
Enter dates to see prices
No other properties are available in Kelleys Island. View nearby results below.
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
#4 Best Value of 4 places to stay in Lakeside
Enter dates to see prices
K B
@K B
Reviewed on 16 Sept 2019
Old hotel in very nice shape
"I used to go to Lakeside as a child to my grandparent's cottage. Frankly at that time, we never noticed the Hotel Lakeside which has been here since 1875. But times change, the cottage is no longer in the family..."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 3 places to stay in Lakeside
Enter dates to see prices
Inn
Jodi Jensen
@leathermermaid
Reviewed on 16 Oct 2019
A step out of the hustle and bustle and into fun and relaxation.
"If you are considering a visit to Lakeside, do it, next, consider staying at the Keystone. It is centrally located to shops, the waterfront and most importantly, you can sit in the enclosed front porch or enjoy the..."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 4 places to stay in Lakeside
Enter dates to see prices
Hostel
SlRiv R
@SlRiv R
Reviewed on 10 Nov 2016
Convenient for our guests
"Each year, we have a youth conference in Lakeside. Some of the local rentals do not want youth in their homes. Maxwell House is always willing and able to accommodate us. We are thankful for their hospitality!"
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 1 place to stay in Lakeside
Enter dates to see prices
37Manifestation
@37Manifestation
Reviewed on 20 Jul 2023
Little overnight trip
"Upon checking in, we encountered some issues. Ted was very kind and compassionate and resolved our issue in a kind and professional and timely manner. He is an asset to your establishment. The room was clean, but..."
Read all reviews
#3 Best Value of 3 places to stay in Lakeside
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
PedsPulm
@PedsPulm
Reviewed on 10 Jul 2023
3 nights at Lakeside!
"We love to come here when we visit Lakeside - a Chautauqua. Never want to leave. The breakfasts are gourmet and so delicious! The rooms are Victorian as Lakeside celebrates 150 years this summer! We also stayed..."
Read all reviews
#2 Best Value of 4 places to stay in Lakeside
Enter dates to see prices
Inn
vnbond
@vnbond
Reviewed on 15 Jul 2022
Wonderful Inn!
"Our room was clean and very cute."
Read all reviews
#2 Best Value of 5 places to stay in Marblehead
Enter dates to see prices
Camping/Caravan site
#2 Best Value of 7 places to stay in Marblehead
Enter dates to see prices
Motel
brenwood12
@brenwood12
Reviewed on 29 Jun 2022
Great Lake Erie location
"Great location . It is very clean. The one walls are rather thin but it is an older motel. We did not expect a 5 star for the price. Over all very satisfied . The Staff was friendly and helpful. Nice view of the..."
Read all reviews
#2 Best Value of 3 places to stay in Marblehead
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
Derek B
@Falccros
Reviewed on 22 Aug 2016
Wonderful B&B in a quaint, albeit, quirky, private community
"The Idlewyld is a 140 year old heritage property lovingly maintained and run by a wonderful couple. Hand made quilts, cross stitch work, and incredible breakfasts will great you every day. The hosts are a wealth..."
Read all reviews
#3 Best Value of 4 places to stay in Lakeside
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
Teena S
@teenas2433
Reviewed on 7 May 2023
Beautiful, welcoming, and convenient
"Our “room” was actually an apartment with a living room/kitchenette and a large bedroom and bath."
Read all reviews
#4 Best Value of 5 places to stay in Marblehead
Enter dates to see prices
Inn
magnumpi12
@magnumpi12
Reviewed on 21 Jul 2019
Overnight Stay At Lighthouse Resort
"Staff was courteous. Our room had a kitchenette that we didn't use. Basic room. King bed. Very firm mattress. Very old blanket. Hot out so AC ran almost all of the time. Room could have been cleaner. The pool was ok..."
Read all reviews
#5 Best Value of 5 places to stay in Marblehead
Enter dates to see prices
Guesthouse
Cathy K
@cathyk433
Reviewed on 5 Sept 2021
Clean and friendly!
"This motel is across the road from Lake Erie; plenty of outdoor seating and grills available. Owners are very friendly and helpful. We were in a first floor room...think small but clean and nicely decorated. Close..."
Read all reviews
#3 Best Value of 5 places to stay in Marblehead
Enter dates to see prices
Phyllis B
@I7862MNphyllisb
Reviewed on 27 Aug 2022
Majestic motel Lakeside Ohio
"Very rude owner. Poorly run manager The internet ad says pets welcome. It their Facebook add says pets cost$50 extra. Came to my room and told me to leave or they would call the police He finally accepted my..."
Read all reviews
#3 Best Value of 3 places to stay in Marblehead
Enter dates to see prices
Camping/Caravan site
#5 Best Value of 7 places to stay in Marblehead
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
#8 Best Value of 10 places to stay in Port Clinton
Enter dates to see prices
Camping/Caravan site
#1 Best Value of 7 places to stay in Marblehead
Kelleys Island Hotels Information
Hotels in Kelleys Island | 13 |
---|---|
Hotels Prices From | £150 |
Hotels Reviews | 702 |
Hotels Photos | 310 |
Travel high season | Jun - Aug |
Travel low season | Dec - Feb |
High season avg price | £189 |
Low season avg price | £110 |
Not sure when to visit?
Price trends, weather and things to do can help you make a decision.
Season
Avg. price/night
Avg. temperature
Avg. precipitation
Dec - Feb
Avg. price/night
£174
LOWEST
£158£558
Avg. temperature
0ºC
COLDEST
-16ºC33ºC
Avg. precipitation
20in
DRIEST
18 in41 in
Mar - May
Avg. price/night
£212
£158£558
Avg. temperature
9ºC
-16ºC33ºC
Avg. precipitation
31in
18 in41 in
Jun - Aug
Avg. price/night
£270
HIGHEST
£158£558
Avg. temperature
22ºC
WARMEST
-16ºC33ºC
Avg. precipitation
39in
WETTEST
18 in41 in
Sep - Nov
Avg. price/night
£245
£158£558
Avg. temperature
13ºC
-16ºC33ºC
Avg. precipitation
29in
18 in41 in
Price trend information excludes taxes and fees and is based on base rates for a nightly stay for 2 adults found in the last 7 days on our site and averaged for commonly viewed hotels in Kelleys Island. Select dates and complete search for nightly totals inclusive of taxes and fees.
Hotels near the sights
- Glacial Grooves State MemorialRead more
- Kelleys Island State ParkRead more
- Charles Herndon Sculpture Garden and GalleriesThe Charles Herndon Sculpture Garden and Galleries is an outdoor Sculpture Garden and collection of galleries that showcases work by Ohio based sculptor Charles Herndon. You will see sculptures of many different forms and materials including steel, stone, bronze, aluminum and concrete. Charles also paints and has many paintings and prints on display. Come to check out the work and leave with a Charles Herndon original! Walk around the gardens and notice the houses, many built 1900 or before. Sculptures abound by the water and around the property. The property is a residence so please be respectful of the people who live here! The Galleries and Gardens also hosts guest artists.Read more
- Kelleys Island Historical AssociationKelleys Island History Museum & gift shop. The grounds include a beautifully restored 1866 stone church and 1888 parsonage which serves as our resale shop. this is simply THE place to discover the remarkable history of Kelleys Island.Read more
- Scheele PreserveRead more
- North Pond State Nature PreserveRead more
- Jones PreserveRead more
Frequently Asked Questions about Kelleys Island hotels
- Put-in-Bay Condos, The Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel, and Waters Edge Retreat are some of the most popular hotels for travellers looking to stay near Glacial Grooves State Memorial. See the full list: Hotels near Glacial Grooves State Memorial.
- Popular hotels close to Kelleys Island State Park include Put-in-Bay Condos, The Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel, and Waters Edge Retreat. See the full list: Hotels near Kelleys Island State Park.
- Popular hotels close to Hopkins Intl Airport include Hilton Garden Inn Cleveland Airport, Best Western Airport Inn & Suites Cleveland, and The Orbit Hotel. See the full list: Hotels near Hopkins Intl Airport.
- A few of the most popular hotels near Inscription Rock Petroglyphs are Waters Edge Retreat, Kelleys Island Venture Resort, and Surf Motel. See the full list: Hotels near Inscription Rock Petroglyphs.