We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Food - Picture of NYPD Pizza Lake Cay, Orlando

Photo: Food

From Review : Worst eggplant parmesan I've ever had! of NYPD Pizza Lake Cay
Worst eggplant parmesan  I've ever had!
Good Pizza Good Service
Worst eggplant parmesan  I've ever had!
Коробка с пиццей
NYPD Pizza
Was not very appetizing....
Get food delivered
FoodandWineReviews wrote a review Jun 2016
Laguna Beach, California186 contributions160 helpful votes
So disappointed in NYPD pizza! I Came here because I love Italian food; but I have to say this is just not for me and probably not for a lot of people. I really have to wonder how it got decent reviews from other trip advisor reviewers??? On the upside the service was very
Read more
Date of visit: June 2016
Response from Jeff L, Owner at NYPD Pizza Lake Cay
Responded 9 Jun 2016
I am sorry that you did not have an enjoyable dining experience with us. I always feel like we failed when everyone is not totally satisfied after visiting our restaurant. When I first read your review, I thought we may have prepared a subpar dish for you. However, upon reviewing the pictures you included it looks like the dish was made to our specifications. The only thing missing from the picture was the side salad that would have been included in this $11.00 entrée. It seems as you were most unhappy with the perceived value of the meal. We spend a lot of time reviewing our menu to make sure we balance our portion size to a reasonable price, based on the quality of our ingredients and our preparation methods. I find your questioning the authenticity and/or palate (???) of our customers who reviewed us before you a little offensive. We understand that we cannot always make everyone happy, but my staff works extremely hard whether you do dine-in, take out, or delivery to provide an enjoyable experience for everyone. We take all feedback very seriously. It always gives us the opportunity to review our policies and procedures based on the legitimate reviews of our food quality and level of service. I’m glad you enjoyed the service and the pizza, and hope you will give us another chance when you are in the area.
Read more
Been to NYPD Pizza Lake Cay? Share your experience!