We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Entrance - Picture of Onofrio's Italian Restaurant, Mastic Beach

Photo: Entrance

From Review : Nice surprise while visiting Fire Island NP of Onofrio's Italian Restaurant

Onofrio's Italian Restaurant

30 reviews
#3 of 16 restaurants in Mastic Beach
  • Nice surprise while visiting Fire Island NP
  • This place is original and one of the last places that has a romantic candle lit dinner atmosphe
  • This place is original and one of the last places that has a romantic candle lit dinner atmosphe
Nice surprise while visiting Fire Island NP
This place is original and one of the last places that has a romantic candle lit dinner atmosphe
This place is original and one of the last places that has a romantic candle lit dinner atmosphe
Nice surprise while visiting Fire Island NP
This place is original and one of the last places that has a romantic candle lit dinner atmosphe

Other Recent Reviews

Love this place!
January 2019
Quaint, cozy, fun
September 2018
Read all 30 reviews
NationalParksTrails wrote a review Jun 2016
San Luis Obispo, California1,847 contribution270 helpful votes
+3
Nice surprise while visiting Fire Island NP
Was looking for a good restaurant in the area and I found it. I was only patron in there when I arrived and it turns out this is mostly locals eating here. The proprietor Patty sat me down and let me know what was good. Everything turned out great with a lot of local flavor. …
Read more
Date of visit: June 2016
Been to Onofrio's Italian Restaurant? Share your experience!