Divya on the till she is so friendly and kind. Always smile on face she made my day wonderful thanks cromars

Takeaway chips from Cromars at 8.45p.m. on a week night? Please don't waste your money. We paid £3.50 per portion for what would amount to perhaps 2 medium-sized potatoes. Counter service was poor with staff more interested in their personal conversation than paying attention to...customers. However, we would probably have overlooked all of the above if the main event - the chips - had lived up to Cromars self-proclaimed reputation as 'the best fish and chips in Scotland' . Unfortunately, we were sadly disappointed. The chips were truly appalling - almost cold, dry and wrinkled. You know that feeling of being well-and-truly ripped off? That will be my abiding memory of Cromar's. Needless to say, we won't be back.More

Overpriced and substandard fish and chips. The batter lacks any consistency and the chips are greasy but mostly chipped too small and feels like the bottom of the basket every time..dry and burnt. I’m sure the actual fish is ok but such is the mess...of the rest of a supper, it’s hard to tell. We used to debate which Chippy in St Andrews was the best. Cromars or the Tailend. Hands down the Tailend is far better value. Plus you don’t need to wait half an hour every time in a queue. And I don’t buy the ‘made fresh every time’ excuse since it wouldn’t make any difference to the taste if there was orders made and being kept warm, like every other chippy. No it’s a cost cutting tactic to avoid any waste at the customers expense. The ordering and service process is terrible and takes more time than it does to actually make a fish supper. Won’t be back.More

Go for the deep fried mars bar. It is melt in your mouth on the inside yet crispy and fresh on the outside. Service was a bit slow. But must try.More

Very expensive for large fish and chips and small portions. Wouldn't recommend this place as I've had large and betterr suppers elsewhere. Plus. They didn't cost an arm and a leg.

By far the most expensive (£12.50) fish supper I've ever had, and the smallest, fish was tiny. Felt royally ripped off

Great fish and chips. Mac n cheese was wonderful also. Best part was the owner who provided our best welcome to St Andrew’s. We’ll be back!More

Wendy and the team couldn’t have been more helpful! We were a large group (like, 23 fish suppers plus more!!) and she happily took our order and had it ready to go for us. Very grateful and we’ll definitely be back next year!

The standard has definitely slipped over the last couple of years. Having looked forward to a trip to Cromars we were disappointed with the below average chips (cold and semi soggy) and the batter left your stomach feeling rather uncomfortable. Seems like they’re riding the...wave of complacency from their highs of a few years ago.More

We have been having carry-outs from Cromar's and its predecessor Peter Michael's for over 30 years, but NO MORE! An exceptionally disappointing meal - burnt mozzarella sticks, mushy peas that had been so stewed that they were black, small amount of fish overcooked to dryness,...incinerated fish cakes that were the day's special. Avoid.More

This restaurant was suggested by our tour guide for fish and chips. I didn’t have the proper fish and chips but instead I chose fish cakes, chips, mushy peas and tartare. The fish cakes were good , really tasty. A bit overpriced though !More

First class fish and chips. Consistently good and friendly professional service. What’s not to like?