PESTELLO, Castellina In Chianti

Based on the managment response from other reviews here they'll probably going to accuse me of something as this seems to be their approach... Tbone was undercooked eventhough we asked for medium well and retuned it twice.... the meat was chewy but that's not the...More

Date of visit: October 2019

Helpful?

Dear Danielel123, we will reply as we have always answered to everyone, but only to give our own version and not leave your bad review without a positive ending. We are sorry that you didn't appreciate our traditional Tuscan cuisine, perhaps too far from your...More

michellewJ1609QS

3 reviews

Reviewed 22 September 2019 via mobile

Holiday visit

Thank you so much for your kind hospitality. Truly authentic Tuscan restaurant with great service. The T bone steak was amazing as were our starter bruschetta dishes. We will visit you again!

Date of visit: September 2019

Helpful?

DejanRomih

13 reviews

Reviewed 22 September 2019 via mobile

After 12 years, still perfect

Extremely happy to return after 12 years. Hospitality and kindness of staff is incredible. Food amazing, everything with truffles is delicious. If you are visiting the region then you need to stop for a dinner in Pestello

Date of visit: September 2019

Helpful?

BALDWIN2

247 reviews

Reviewed 30 August 2019

Food was not tasty and not matching the price

I was there following the rate they received. The restaurant was more than half empty , one waiter who also caters the bar nearby. All dishes served were not of good quality and were extremely disappointed. Not recommendedMore

Date of visit: August 2019

Helpful?2

Dear Baldwin2, We are sorry that you didn’t like our food we serve from 25 years with good quality and several clients along the years we have the restaurant, but we have two separate ambience: the bar and the restaurant and we have two different...More

fredk419

10 reviews

Reviewed 24 August 2019

Great food, friendly atmosphere

We were repeat customers at Pestello during our week at a nearby agriturismo. Rabbit, wild boar, and, of course, the bistecca fiorentina were highlights. Had some great tiramisu and panna cotta for desserts. The friendly hosting and neighborhood atmosphere were the icing on the cake!

Date of visit: August 2019

Helpful?

DyfedW

2 reviews

Reviewed 9 August 2019 via mobile

Perfecto!

Having visited Pestello 6 times over a 3 year period I can confirm that the food and service is as excellent as ever. As a family we’ve always looked forward to dining at this Tuscan restaurant. The meal usually starts with a selection of homemade...More

Date of visit: August 2019

Helpful?

Navigator557618

48 reviews

Reviewed 5 August 2019 via mobile

Delicious!

We were 3 couples on holiday in Tuscany and found this restaurant on Trip Advisor. After reading the raving reviews, we booked online and were not disappointed! The service and food were fantastic! Between the six of us, we had the wild boar shank, the...More

Date of visit: August 2019

Helpful?2

FoodieReviewee

40 reviews

Reviewed 9 July 2019 via mobile

A Real Gem!

One of our favorite restaurants over our 10 days in Italy! I had the asparagus pesto and loved it! My husband’s veal dish was the best veal dish he has ever had! Family owned and operated. We went back for a 2nd night!

Date of visit: May 2019

Helpful?

JMcCauley425

3 reviews

Reviewed 6 July 2019 via mobile

Delicious Tuscan Meal

One of the best meals we ate during our 2 week trip in Italy!! The steak was to die for, perfectly cooked and incredibly flavorful - a must order! Their grilled vegetables and homemade pasta (pici cacio e pepe) were also delicious, and they have...More

Date of visit: July 2019

Helpful?

TomandMary

18 reviews

Reviewed 14 June 2019

Sometimes getting lost pays off!!

Found this amazing restaurant because we were lost in the hills of Castellina in Chianti. The restaurant wasn’t open yet but we stopped to see if they could help with directions to the Hotel we just could not find on all those tiny roads. Maria...More