Very much a mixed bag. For a change, I'll bullet-point the good, the so-so, and the not so good.
Good - atmosphere, menu selection, wine selection, starter of goat's cheese, mains of pigeon. The latter two were absolutely excellent.
So-so - starter of pate, mains...of fish and chips (despite the fish being plonked on top of the mushy peas, leading to the fish having a "soggy bottom"), dessert of apple crumble (despite the crumble not being "proper" crumble), and service ( I had spilt something on the table after my mains, but it was left there for the rest of the meal).
Not so good - apostrophe abuse on the main page of the web site, and the appallingly bad profiteroles ( a steak knife to cut through them would have been advisable). The confirmation of my on-line booking also referred to the fact that I had been "approved" for my booking - what investigative methods are used to approve me? The chairs were a bit hard, causing my wife to fidget uncomfortably after about 45 minutes.
So, a little bit of a curate's egg. If the restaurant can replicate the excellence of the "good" items elsewhere, apply small alterations to the "so-so" items, and eliminate the "not so good" items, then a stunning venue will surely result.More