After coming here 18 years, it never disappoints. The bread is the best on island. Especially the oatmeal. Sheila's favorite is always a family favorite. And don't forget the cookies! They are also best on island.
11 - 20 of 237 reviews
Stopped by for another visit. Had a delicious 1/2 turkey swiss on multigrain bread baked at 4 am this morning. Added lettuce, tomatoes, soroits, and red onion for no extra charge. Awesome sandwich. Split a peanut butter cookie with my friend. Bought some local honey...More
My favorite sandwich shop!!! I love the hummus and veggie sandwich. They have delicious homemade bread and mouth-watering cookies! There is usually a line to order, but it is well worth the wait! Great place to pick up sandwiches to take to the beach. Also...More
Our family has been to this Nantucket Classic many times. It is always a great lunch. Fresh healthy options and sit outside on the picnic benches. We had salad we select, Hummus and Sprouts, Avocado and Cheddar, and Turkey Wonderful home made Portuguese bread. Strong...More
As always, this is my favorite sandwich shop on the island. I always get the smoked turkey, lettuce, tomato and cheese with sprouts on Portuguese bread with mayo. I usually get a 1/2 sandwich but this time I got a whole, a BIG sandwich. My...More
This is the place locals like myself favor when we have visiting guests. Superb sandwiches, generous in size, and a relaxing ambience.
We sat outside at Something Natural in early October. The sandwiches were delicious and the atmosphere was beautiful and relaxed. The staff is pleasant and there are plenty of choices to eat. Excellent bread. I highly recommend the BLT. Be sure to have a Matt...More
Bread is wonderful! Many delicious choices for sandwiches. prices are reasonable too. We found the half sandwich to be enough for lunch. They also make the cranberry bread for the annual cranberry festival- divine!