All photos (124)
All photos (124)
Travellers' Choice

Ratings and reviews

4.0 1,243 reviews
#15 of 66 American in Nantucket
#15 of 83 Restaurants in Nantucket
Travellers' Choice
RATINGS
Food
Service
Value
Atmosphere

Food and ambience

Local cuisine, American, Bar, Pub, Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options
Great burgers, good drinks.Great menu and burger choices at lunch.
Special Occasion Dining, Groups, Bar Scene
Great food and beersGreat pub with great bar

Location and contact

23 Broad St, Nantucket, MA 02554-3502
Website
+1 508-228-2551
Improve this listing

Menu

SOUPS
Island Quahog Chowder
Cup $7.95
Bowl $9.95
Lobster Bisque
$10.95
French Onion Soup
$9.95
Seasonal Potage
Cup $6.95
Bowl $8.95
SPECIALTY SALADS
add hormone free chicken $5.00 or seared crab cake $7.00
Brogo Caesar Salad
romaine lettuce, roasted tomatoes, kalamata olives, imported parmesan, garlic croutons, caesar dressing
$12.95
Chicken Milanese Salad
pan fried chicken breast, arugala, roasted tomatoes, balsamic glazed cippolini onions, parmesan, xvoo, red wine demiglace
$17.95
Summer Greens
walnut crusted local goat cheese, bib lettuce, shaved fennel, marinated blackberries, xvoo
$14.95
The Lobster Cobb
fresh lobster claw and knuckle meat, hard boiled egg, cob smoked bacon, cherry tomato, red onion, avocado, poppy seed ranch dressing
$23.95
Smoke House Wedge Salad
jumbo seared tuna, baby greens, cucumber, pea shoots, pickled ginger, wasabi peas, marinated rice noodles, orange - sesame vinaigrette
$20.95
DINNER ENTREES
Broiled Chatham Cod
traditional crumbs, starch of the evening, seasonal vegetable
$19.95
Broiled Seasonal Scallops
traditional crumbs, starch of the evening, seasonal vegetables
Market Price
Bistro Steak Frites
12 oz certified angus n.y. strip, parmesan herb frites, sauteed spinach, mushroom demi glace, garlic aioli
$25.95
Winter Primavera
roasted garlic fettuccine, carrots, sundried tomatoes, butternut squash, spinach, fresh herbs, parmesan
$14.95
Add Grilled Chicken $3.00
Fried Bay Scallop Escabeche
local bay scallops, carrots, red onion, bell pepper, butternut squash, malt vinegar marinade, garlic crostini
$20.95
SIDES
Broho Curly Fries
$5.95
Local Fried Pickles
$6.95
Sweet Potato Fries
$6.95
Seasonal Vegetables
$6.95
Parmesan Herb Frites
$6.95
Petit Salad
house or caesar
$7.95
DESSERTS
Chocolate Mousse Martini
milano cookie, blackberries, whipped cream
$9.00
Oreo Ice Cream Cake
locally produced by the ice cream machine
$9.00
Bloned Of Thieves
warm chocolate chip cookie, vanilla ice cream, fudge sauce
$9.00
Lemon Blueberry Tart
made with lemon infused local goat cheese
$9.00
Show full menu

Details

Special Diets
Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options
Meals
Lunch, Dinner, Brunch, After-hours, Drinks
CUISINES
American, Bar, Pub
FEATURES
Takeout, Outdoor Seating, Seating, Television, Highchairs Available, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Accepts Credit Cards, Table Service, Live Music
Reviews (1,243)
Write a review
Filter reviews
1,230 results
Traveller rating
438
495
203
61
33
Traveller type
Time of year
LanguageEnglish
More languages
Traveller rating
438
495
203
61
33
Show reviews that mention
All reviews curly fries burger chowder salad turkey club calamari lobster roll seafood sandwiches low ceilings great atmosphere a late lunch off season bot island pub bartender
Selected filters
FilterEnglish
Updating list...
Reviewed 19 October 2020
Front desk recommendation.

We asked the White Elephant front desk “where do the locals eat” and were told this restaurant. The menu and prices were great however the service and atmosphere were poor.

Date of visit: October 2020
Helpful?
Reviewed 26 September 2020 via mobile
Had better visits

We always hit up the Brotherhood everytime we're on the island, but were disappointed this time. Service was slow and not the best. Food was average at best. We were seated upstairs, which isn't our favorite and this time seemed like they were just stashing...More

Date of visit: July 2020
Helpful?2  
Reviewed 13 September 2020 via mobile
DONT SKIP THE......

Don’t skip the peanut butter and jelly pie. Ummm In addition the drinks were amazing. I am always a red wine drinker but they talked me into a drink and even invented one based on our likes and it was awesome. We liked it so...More

Date of visit: September 2020
Helpful?2  
Reviewed 11 September 2020
Wonderful

Short and sweet.....this great spot. Service is friendly and efficient, food and drink are delicious. The crab cake sliders were some of the best crab cakes I've ever had and the bushwhackers rivaled those I've had in the Caribbean. Add Brotherhood to the list when...More

Date of visit: August 2020
Helpful?
Reviewed 8 September 2020
Great place for lunch

My family and I had a great relaxed lunch here. The clam chowder was delicious and so were the burgers, but the lobster bisque with the flaky crust was really something special. They don't take reservations, but we didn't have a problem getting a seat....More

Date of visit: August 2020
Helpful?1  
Reviewed 29 August 2020 via mobile
Good for a drink & some apps

This worked for us for a quick drink and a bite to eat while shopping in the area. Burger & fries were excellent! It’s a dark tavern kind of atmosphere though, so if you are looking for ambience, keep that in mind! Highly recommend the...More

Date of visit: August 2020
Helpful?
Reviewed 23 August 2020 via mobile
This Restaurant Always Hits the Spot

Great service, casual atmosphere and some great dishes for lunch or dinner. Highly recommend the crab cake sandwich or sliders and the lobster bisque!

Date of visit: August 2020
Helpful?1  
Reviewed 17 August 2020
Eh

Love this old place, but the food has gotten pretty bad. Meanwhile you still pay Nantucket prices. I had some kind of seafood newburge thing that was barely cooked. Surprised I didnt get sick

Date of visit: August 2020
Helpful?2  
Reviewed 10 August 2020
Outstanding

While on Nantucket for a day, we tried the highly recommended Brotherhood of Thieves. For those that want a water view, this is not - it’s in town, a little off the beaten track. But, if you’re looking for excellent food and service, this is...More

Date of visit: August 2020
Helpful?2  
Reviewed 16 July 2020 via mobile
Still outstanding after all these years

Have been coming here since the mid-70s and have never been disappointed Service is prompt and friendly, food is reliably excellent.

Date of visit: July 2020
Helpful?
View more reviews
123456…123
Best nearby
Best nearby hotelsSee all
21 Broad Hotel
258 reviews
.01 miles away
Jared Coffin House
299 reviews
.03 miles away
Hotel Pippa
54 reviews
.04 miles away
Nantucket Resort Collection
706 reviews
.08 miles away
Best nearby restaurantsSee all
The Juice Bar Homemade Ice Cream
663 reviews
.09 miles away
Dune
739 reviews
.02 miles away
Oran Mor
364 reviews
.09 miles away
The Proprietors Bar and Table
251 reviews
.08 miles away
Best nearby attractionsSee all
Whaling Museum
1,586 reviews
.07 miles away
Nantucket Atheneum
108 reviews
.10 miles away
First Congregational Church
78 reviews
.12 miles away
Theatre Workshop of Nantucket
43 reviews
.13 miles away
See the best nearby hotelsSee the best nearby restaurantsSee the best nearby attractions
See all
Questions & Answers
Ask a question
See all 5 questions
susantA6636US
21 August 2019|
AnswerShow all 4 answers
Response from BFree4 | Reviewed this property |
No reservation was needed.
0
Votes
Abby W
24 August 2017|
Answer
Response from terrysO2108SY | Reviewed this property |
I don't know
0
Votes
12
Is This Your Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Free Listing
Frequently Asked Questions about Brotherhood of Thieves
    Does Brotherhood of Thieves offer takeaway?
    Yes, Brotherhood of Thieves offers takeaway services.
    Does Brotherhood of Thieves offer delivery?
    Yes, Brotherhood of Thieves offers delivery services.
    How is Brotherhood of Thieves rated?
    Brotherhood of Thieves is rated accordingly in the following categories by Tripadvisor travellers:
    • Food: 4
    • Service: 4
    • Value: 3.5
    • Atmosphere: 4