A friend recommended, and since we're always looking for new places to try - absolutely loved it! Quaint low key with a burst of flavors! The place smells delish!!!
1 - 10 of 289 reviews
We were hungry for pizza down at the shore, so we searched a while to find a good pizza place and we found it at Mr P Pizza. My wife was getting frustrated with my indecisiveness and were about to give up and just go...More
Excellent. The food and service were great. We had a party of 14 and everything went as planned. The pizza is uniquely high quality with great crust.
I always try to eat here when I'm in the area & in the mood for delicious wood-fired pizza & a local/regional craft brew. If you go (and you SHOULD!), be aware that it is a cash-only establishment.
This restaurant was a great find on our trip. We went with a group of 7 people and ordered 2 medium pizzas which were more than enough to feed everyone. They also have a great selection of local beers on tap.
Visited Mr. P's pizzeria with my family early one evening last week. It was a pleasant surprise to find such great pizza in such an out of the way Place. Service was by far nothing like a NYC pizzeria - no rushing - no pushing...More