Always great pizza, it's a little thicker crust, but if that's what you like it's great. Staff is always friendly.
1 - 10 of 37 reviews
Very good but I prefer takeout.This place is much better than Caruso's Bistro because of the price. Caruso's Bistro is way overpriced and really not worth the extra money.
My family and I have been going here for a long time. We moved here over 14 years ago and have always gone to Middletown Pizza. They know you by name and make it a priority to provide only the best quality food. They also...More
Few independently owned restaurants make it this long so that says something for their food. Always clean and neat. MP attracts the locals and portions are good size and they make awesome salads. Pizza is distinctive and have grown to really enjoy the uniqueness of...More
We go here to eat quite a bit and pizza is what we get most often. Recently discovered The Rancher- an amazing pizza with chicken, bacon, and ranch pizza that has become our family favorite. I would highly recommend it. They make giant cheesesteaks as...More
The food is good and plentiful. They make a GREAT chopped antipasto salad!!!! Their eggplant parmesan hero is also a great meal.
This pizza place is popular with the local community so that is a good sign. However, pizza tastes are very individual so be your own guide
Wife and I went to the local movies and did shopping and visited this eatery for lunch. We had a pizza and a Veal Parm Sub. Both were very good and we took home the leftovers. Will return again.
We've lived in Middletown for a few years now and were regulars at Pat's until lately. Pat's seems to have changed management and quality and service were effected so we had to try a new place. Middletown Pizza is the closest to us, so we...More
Pizza was okay. Steak sandwich okay. Good fries. Atmosphere old school comfortable pizza joint. Went with friends would return if asked, but would not personally pick this restaurant.