Their ice cream is the best!! Especially their Salted Caramel!!! Place stays busy although staff does great job getting people in and out. Must try when on the island!
151 - 160 of 1,007 reviews
Every time we visit Fernandino Beach we must stop by Fantastic Fudge. They actually make the fudge on site and offer several mouth watering varieties including my favorite peanut butter and chocolate swirl. We usually buy a several flavors to take home to our families....More
We love stopping at Fantastic Fudge for a cup of ice cream! It is very fresh and tastes fantastic! Highly recommend stopping here if you are in the area!
Your blood sugar could go completely out of control at this fudge, candy and ice cream shop. Hands down the best chocolate fudge I've ever had (I don't like to adulterate my fudge with nuts or anything) and I've had a lot. I always bring...More
Ate nearby for dinner and took a walk down Center St to find this little store crowded on a week night. Had to wait almost 10 min but it was well worth it. Grabbed a single scoop in a cup to share with my husband...More
The Fantastic Fudge shop was perfect for us. We wanted ice cream, but we are both watching what we eat. We asked for their smallest size and they provided 1/2 scoops for us--perfect! I've never had an ice cream shop customize something for us. We...More