Go there and eat fantastic pizza Go there soon. Real Italians making real pizza. And it is wonderful!
1 - 10 of 1,283 reviews
I haven't been able to find any Pizza as good as New York Pizza since I came to Key West 20 years ago. Until now. This was an Italian New York Pizza at it's finest.
Seriously, I’m Italian and I love me some spaghetti and meatballs and this was some of the best I’ve had in years. So yummy.
We started with the homemade mozzarella stuffed with various things. So good! I ordered the lasagna. Served piping hot with flavorful sauce. My husband and children ate two types of pizza. My husband compared the crust to the pizza crust in Italy. Great service! Highly...More
Can’t talk about the staff or restaurant, but the pizza is fabulous! We make Neapolitan pizza in our wood fired oven at home and I have to admit it—-Onlywood’s is better than ours—-go figure?
Delicious salad and Magareta pizza. Fresh ingredients and baked in brick/lava rock oven. Enjoyed listening to the chef sing along to the Italian music. And especially enjoyed the Key West feel with a kitty cat under my chair and a hen and two chicks on...More
just trying to be friendly - Are you from Italy, and it went down hill quick. Just a customer asking a simple question was enough to make the server never return to the table. Food was ok, outside and very humid and HOT, but awful...More
Sunday nice sitting at the bar and a girl picks up a bottle and uses her teeth to pull out the cork. NOOOOOO Yes, and we sat at the bar and watched this happen. Service was very very bad - However the Pizza was great,...More
We came here on the advice of a local, we were excited. We sat and 5 minutes later our server approached and ask for our drink order, we’d been day drinking and we’re exhausted from the 2 mike walk to get there so we asked...More
We arrived just as the restaurant was opening and were happy we arrived when we did. It filled up fast. There is indoor and outdoor seating. Outdoor looked lovely. We chose indoor for the air conditioning. Ordered the happy hour Sangria...delicious. Wood fired pizzas and...More