Fantastic atmosphere, amazing food and drink options. Lots of gluten free options marked on the menu.
11 - 20 of 942 reviews
We went there with mom and dad for dinner January 1, 2018 at 6pm. There were 5 of us. All of us had identical meals- soup and salad. The black bean soup was good, for sure. Not fabulous, but definitely good. The Mayan soup was...More
The best rack of lamb worth more than $50 but is only $20+, amazing dish. All dishes were gourmet very high quality!!! Laughing when comparing it to "Columbian" up the street....pls spend r $$$ here & really have a good time!! Please post the pic...More
We had lunch and had our hog with us. They actually brought a dish of water for the dog. We ordered chips and salsa and was pleasantly surprised by the chips. The salsa was tasty and not too spicy. My wife had the tacos with...More
There are so many choices in St. AUGUSTINE, but we wanted seafood, so we took a chance because Casa Maya calls itself a Mexican Seafood Grill. Well, we gambled and won. Everything was tops. We were three. We shared a flight of tequila, which were...More
My wife and I, exhausted and hungry from fighting the crowds on St. George Street, retired to Casa Maya for a special dinner. We have had breakfast and lunch here, but never dinner. It was delicious. I had something I had never tried before--essentially Carne...More
We both said at the same time ...the Ceviche at Casa Maya. Great as always and the top shelf Margaritas are for real! Great chips and salsa!
Weekend visit for the nights of lights. FreezIng cold evening. Didn't book. Was seated and served by Amber. Nice G&T', Rum Tiki cocktail and local craft beers. Paella for 2 people. I had that hanger steak RARE...and it actually came rare... Gorgeous Shredded beef for...More
Popped in for their ropa vieja and it did not disappoint. Clean flavors and also a great hanger steak and octopus ceviche. Finish it off with one of their jalapeño and cucumber margaritas. The only downside from our visit was an abundance of loud children,...More
My husband and I enjoyed dinner on our last night. Great food and service with attention to detail. Not your typical food.