One of the better deep dishes in Chicago! Crust was crisp, sauce and cheese were very fresh, and toppings were flavorful. This place should be higher on people’s radar for experiencing Chicago deep dish!
1 - 10 of 31 reviews
The pizza here is the best I have ever had. There used to be several of these throughout the United States. I have eaten My Pi in Miami and Phoenix and Chicago. Sadly, only the Chicago location remains..and it has moved from Fullerton and Clark...More
This place was recommended by Ray at Ray's Bucktown B&B. We each had a slice of deep dish pizza and it was the best we'd tried.It's a small place with some seats indoors and some outdoors. Worth it!!
Best crust ever!!! It is perfect. Cheese was just right and the other topping were good, not plentiful but good. You can skip the "chain" pizza places cause they wont be as good as here. The place is super small as it only sits about...More
We stopped for pizza and rather than order and wait for a deep dish, we opted for a couple of deep dish slices. We got a sausage piece, a sausage and pepperoni piece and a mushroom piece. They were flavorful, but with slices, you do...More
So, I stopped by here to get a slice of pizza on my way out of Chicago. I was enjoying trying pizza at different places, and I found that this slice unfortunately fell a bit short. Don't get me wrong, the pizza was good (if...More
Tonight in Huntersville NC our family enjoyed pan pizza from My Pie in Chicago. We ordered four deep dish on-line and they arrived as scheduled, frozen. We thawed in fridge and baked each in our own oven for a bit over 25 minutes and they...More
This place rocks. They serve a small deep dish (enough for one hungry person), which is great for me and my wife, as she doesn't like deep dish. The thin crust is awesome as well. Thanks My Pie!!
My past experience with Chicago deep dish has been love/hate. I love it, but it hates me. My Pie, on the other hand, is the first deep dish pizza that hasn't made me sick. The crust has the typical deep dish consistency, but without as...More
On my first non-work visit to Chicago, I tried to make it a point to eat as much deep dish as I could. My Pie came highly recommended off Steve Dolinsky's ratings, and so I took the CTA Blue Line over to Damen, and walked...More