Let’s do the good points first. From the outside the Highwayman is a quaint little pub but inside it’s a veritable Tardis with several, well decorated rooms and tables placed a decent distance apart. Overall this creates a pleasing atmosphere.
The staff were attentive and...helpful and the service, in general, could not be faulted.
For a mid-week lunch there is a good selection of dishes and the prices, considering we are in inflationary 2023, seemed fair. However…. we were both underwhelmed with the food.
I have no doubt the chef knows how to cook and present a dish well. But my garlic mushroom starter was pieces of chopped up mushroom in a soup (they give a spoon with the dish) swimming in an over-creamed sauce, with no trace of garlic whatsoever.
My main course of rabbit pie came, as a previous report mentions, with an open top, so not really a pie. There were minuscule amounts of rabbit in it and what there was could hardly be tasted as, once again, it was awash in an over-powering cream sauce. The same one I wonder as my mushrooms?
My partner often makes a rabbit pie (she gets the rabbit from Vicars not 12 miles away) which is much tastier and filled with meat. So relatively this was very poor but in absolute standards poor as well.
A pity and I could not recommend the place based on this experience.More