We have been going to Scarlet Oak for 40 years, since my wife and I had dinner at the previous Whitton House the night we got engaged. We have had many great dinners there over the years. Alex who used to be a waiter then...manager was outstanding. I made reservations on Tuesday for Saturday evening at 5:30. We were not seated in the dining room as expected but in the tavern. It was loud and we got a blast of cold air when the door opened. Our table was against a window next to the entrance to the tavern and people were constantly passing very closely to our table. I had to pull my elbow in while cutting my steak. After dinner I asked to speak with the dining room manager. I told him up front that I was not looking for anything for free but wanted to let him know that the table should not be located where it was for the previously stated reasons. He looked annoyed with me and asked the hostess for a meal voucher. I told him to keep it as it would be a while before we would return. Sadly we will not be returning anytime soon. Please note that the food was ok, not as good as in the pastMore