We were on the island for chowderfest. We have a hard time ever getting in here so we walked over for lunch. We had margaritas and we shared fried calamari. My dh has a soft shell crab and I had a crab cake. Food was...More
11 - 20 of 397 reviews
Booked for a family group on a midweek evening in late September. The table was not ready for a while due to the previous party taking their time. The hostess was most apologetic and attentive while we waited. Once seated the waiter was outstanding with...More
Yielded to the waitstaff's (Connor ) recommendation of Jambaylaya and bacon wrapped scallops. Both were 5star! Started with PEI mussels, small but plentiful. Don't forget the "on tap" Black Whale Ale and Shape of Hops to Come!
We have eaten dinner at Black Whale many times over the years and it remains consistently good when it comes to food and service. I enjoy the bar too but it can be come very loud and gets so crowed at times that it becomes...More
I had all sea food and everything was excellent. Very friendly staff and bartender. If you love sea food give this place a try you won't be sorry.
Amazing! Best restaurant on LBI. Salad comes with the meal and helps keep the cost reasonable. Always great, never had a bad meal here. Go early wait can be 2 hours plus
Food was exceptionally good. All the seafood we had ordered tasted amazing. Wanted to thank Jeanie a million times over for being the best hostess, she was able to accommodate a party of 9 within minutes. We will definitely be back here again.
Enjoyed the black whale .. it was just ok ! Best part was the garlic ranch salad dressing and the garlic clams. Maybe I just love garlic lol . Had crab clusters which were good but standard . If I sat down in 20 minutes...More
Everytime we are at LBI this is typically our first stop! It's always busy and a little loud in a fun, relaxed atmosphere. We prefer to sit at the bar and wait for a table. It's a friendly place. Once you get to your table,...More