Fantastic lasagna the best I have ever had. Great salad and meet balls too. The owners John, frank and Vincent are great people, Very warm and friendly. My favorite Resturant in bay shore.
1 - 10 of 13 reviews
We had about 10 people so we had pizza's and salads for pick up and it was very good. Fast service, loved the sausage and the salads were great.
Consistently good pizza. Have been stopping by for a few years now, not very often, but a few times a year. The staff always remembers me, which is always nice in a local place. Good guys. Good Food. Win.
Been eating here for 35 years. Frank and John are great guys. We have grown up and old together. Great slices, great food. A huge part of my life from middle school to adulthood
we came across fratelli quite by accident because we are a local business and needed someone to deliver food to us. originally they stated they don't usually deliver by us but they gave in and it was to our advantage. we have been ordering for...More
The snap of a crisp Crisp Crust, Flavorful Sauce, Perfect ratio of cheese. This is what NY pizza is all about. I have been going to Fratelli for years, and still can't figure out how they are not on ever top pizza list around. It...More
We tried them again since we hadn't been there in years. We thought that might have improved but we were wrong. Pizza was as nasty as the staff. We won't be going back.
Lucky me! After being away from Bay Shore Long Island for almost 10 years, there is still a tasty, authentic Italian food place. I asked for Italian Ice and he said he had a few flavors, I thought he would just name 3 but he...More
Family owned resturant, cozy warm inviting place. Great prices on a fresh pie..and dinner dishes are delicious! Great atmosphere where the staff knows you by name.