I try to make sure I'm hungry for lunch when I'm in New Paltz so I can enjoy a yummy meal at P&G's. Trouble is I don't like to vary because the French Onion soup overflowing with cheese and burgers are so darn good. Can't...More
1 - 10 of 190 reviews
Met my daughter here after her college orientation and this was a nice surprise. We all had different sandwiches and really liked the atmosphere here. Will definitely go here again. Service was great and very roomy.
The building lends itself to be noisy, but the staff should take note that large groups make a lot of noise and seat people accordingly. We were seated next to a group of 8 females obviously on a group outing. They were in the party...More
If you visit the town of New Paltz, your visit is not complete unless you have stopped in at P&G's for a bite to eat or just a beer... Ever since my college days, P&G's has always been the face of New Paltz. Good food,...More
My aunt was here for my daughters wedding and I had just picked her up at the airport and we were hungry. When she saw that you had fried green tomato sandwiches and sweet potato fries, she was so happy! I had one also -...More
A local suggested we eat here. I have to say that, first off, the food was pretty good. I had a chicken sandwich and my husband had turkey. The reason for my "average" rating was our server. In reading these Tripadvisor reviews, others were fortunate...More
During the day you can get burgers, fries and beer. Carharts, football jerseys, and ball caps welcome. At night it invites a younger crowd; a great place to bring the side chick, if she misbehaves leave her and go across the street where the other...More
I have moved out of the area, but visit this place whenever I'm in town. I have always loved their burgers and have yet to have any disappointments. It's a great place for nonpretentious dining with 5 star food.