I have loved this pizza for years, but the last time I was there to eat, I was disgusted by how dirty everything is.
Does this restaurant offer takeout or food to go?
Does this restaurant have tables with seating?
Is this an American restaurant?
Is this restaurant good for large groups?
Is this restaurant family-friendly?
Is this a fast food place?
Is this restaurant wheelchair accessible?
Is this restaurant appropriate for Kids?
Are the prices at this restaurant low or inexpensive?
Is this restaurant good for dining on a budget?
Thanks for helping!Share another experience before you go.
This place has been a gold mine for pizza for decades. A simple little pizza shop. For years....I get two slices and lemonade. Best thing ever! This place is small, fresh pizza that you can observe being made. Fresh out of the oven and on to your plate. There is no place like it.
Not worth the $16 for a large pizza anymore. Very disappointing. Won't go there again, after being a customer for 30 years. Called for pick-up, said 15 minutes, was 35 minutes. Gentleman in front of me received a burnt pie. Got his money back; kids working seemed to care less. The place is not the same. They don't seem to... More
Restaurant is in Olean center mall. Worth the trip. Closet pizza in the area to ny pizza! A bit pricey, but worth it.. Try the lemonade. Have been going here for over 20 years.
I love, love, love this pizza! Other reviewers are correct that the restaurant portion needs updated, but it is clean and the food is delicious, hot, and fast. Their cheese pizza and lemonade are my favorites and whenever I'm in the area, I stop in and grab a slice (or pie).
First of all, Renna's is in my opinion, the best pizza in Olean. I have been going there since I was a kid in the 80's. That being said, the place hasn't changed at ALL since that time I've thirty years ago. The restaurant itself is disgusting. It's dirty, the decor is old and dated, the tables are greasy and... More
Their Olean Mall location isn't much to look at but their plain thin crust pizza is the best in town. It has an incredible buttery flavor and is always cooked to perfection. You can't go wrong with a couple (or more) slices of their plain cheese pizza and a glass of their fresh squeezed lemonade.
I grew up near Olean, NY and like most other reviewers, Renna's pizza was a staple in my teenage/Olean Center Mall-trolling years - my friends and I never went there without grabbing a slice or 3 :) - After moving away to a city who claims to have the 'best pizza anywhere', I found myself craving Renna's and attempting to... More
Now I've been to this establishment a few times, each of the previous times the food was outstanding. We generally order the same thing when we come here for my son, chicken tenders with mild buffalo sauce and fries. Anyway on this visit I ordered the stuffed shells which were great, and ordered the chicken tenders, the chicken parm sub... More
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.Claim Your Listing