We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Casa Rustica Restaurant

175 W Main St, Smithtown, NY 11787-2606
+1 631-265-9265
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
Updating Map...
  • Excellent52%
  • Very good27%
  • Average11%
  • Poor6%
  • Terrible4%
Travellers talk about
“lobster” (13 reviews)
“veal chop” (5 reviews)
“branzino” (4 reviews)
Closed Now
11:00 - 22:00All hours
175 W Main St, Smithtown, NY 11787-2606
Write a Review
Reviews (100)
Traveller rating
Traveller type
Time of year

1 - 10 of 100 reviews

Reviewed 1 week ago

We've gone there most years for our wedding anniversary. This year was somewhat disappointing. No one was at the door when we arrived. The bartender didn't acknowledge us, even though he wasn't serving anyone at the time, until we called out to him to get...More

Thank staceyd6
Reviewed 13 May 2017 via mobile

This restaurant has a great chef and all the dishes are excellent. Never a let down. My only complaint is the location of the dining hall. It needs improvements . Food quality is always superb and in my opinion owners will do much better at...More

Thank imran s
Reviewed 9 May 2017 via mobile

Every time we enjoy this restaurant we are taken back to our trips to Italy with fond memories of excellent Italian food. The stuffed veal chop is outstanding, the fish is always the freshest around prepared how you like it. I would recommend the risotto...More

Thank marie s
Reviewed 1 May 2017 via mobile

Awesome food; never disappointed. Two family members ordered from restaurant week menu, where portions were plentiful and food (crab cake and beat salad appetizers and veal scallopini) were delicious. Another family member ordered scallops and lasagna from regular menu and was very happy. Side of...More

Thank HannahLee123
Reviewed 16 April 2017

Evening dinner on Easter Sunday with my wife. We shared an order of Mushroom Risotto as an appetizer as we've had this dish before. It did not disappoint - creamy and so tasteful. My wife had the Rack of Lamb and they accommodated her request...More

Thank Joelny14
Reviewed 11 April 2017 via mobile

NYC dining on Long Island. Prices are great the food and service even better. Great location in heart of Smithtown NY Ask for Benny

Thank Tony L
Reviewed 10 April 2017

Casa Rustica never truly disappoints. On my most recent visit to celebrate a birthday, we were escorted to the "lower" of the two dining rooms. While I prefer the upper level near the bar, the room was warm and inviting and we were immediately greeted...More

Thank Catherine H
Reviewed 25 March 2017 via mobile

First let me take it from the beginning. I called Casa Rustica and had the distinct displeasure to speak with someone named Benny. It was apparent that Benny could not be bothered to speak with me and his arrogance and belligerence were surpassed only by...More

Thank Scott R
Reviewed 18 February 2017

Our first visit to Casa Rustica and we will be frequenting again. Did not have reservations so had a short wait at the bar - friendly bar tender, excellent service. Dinner was delicious. Salmon special was cooked to perfection, with excellent flavorings. Buratta was flavorful,...More

Thank mktravelej
Reviewed 17 February 2017 via mobile

From outside the place looks old and small but like Italian catacombs it's going on and on. The bar is extremely good and probably is the best place to be. The restaurant has nice selection but service is slow and you keep have a feeling...More

Thank Leo G
Nearby Restaurants
Chop Shop
114 reviews
.46 miles away
Aji 53
51 reviews
.57 miles away
Thai House
94 reviews
.28 miles away
Nearby Attractions
Croxley Ale House Smithtown
33 reviews
.07 miles away
St. James General Store
17 reviews
2.47 miles away
Escape Zone Long Island
8 reviews
3.01 miles away
Blydenburgh Park
30 reviews
3.16 miles away
Questions & AnswersAsk a question
Kenneth B
parking nearby
19 December 2015|
Answer Show all 3 answers
Response from TerriJohn | Reviewed this property |
They have valet ,but terrible service and an overpriced menu
Improve this listing

Restaurant Details

Rating summary
  • Food
  • Value
Average prices
Lunch, Dinner
Restaurant features
Reservations, Seating, Waitstaff, Parking Available, Valet Parking, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar
Good for
Child-friendly, Romantic, Business meetings, Special Occasion Dining, Groups
Open Hours
14:00 - 21:00
11:00 - 21:00
11:00 - 21:00
11:00 - 21:00
11:00 - 22:00
17:00 - 23:00
Location and Contact Information
  • Address: 175 W Main St, Smithtown, NY 11787-2606
  • Location: United States  >  New York (NY)  >  Long Island  >  Smithtown
  • Phone Number: +1 631-265-9265
  • E-mail
Is This Your TripAdvisor Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more. Claim Your Listing