By far the best fish in this Midwest market. Servers are fair. Not many care. Desert can be excellent. Key Lime is super although sometimes they serve old pie. You can tell it has been sitting around by the consistency.
1 - 10 of 473 reviews
I asked this question and the response was "east coast". Excuse me?!?! Are they Blue Points, Wellfleets, Belons, etc. So I said can you go back and ask again. And again the server said "east coast". Now if you are a restaurant that serves seafood,...More
The first time I ate here was in November, for my sister's birthday and I was hooked! I've gone back at least five times. The raw oysters are the best I've ever had. Based on that, I ordered the charbroiled oysters. Do yourself a favor,...More
First time here as we were travelling to Indiana and were looking for a good fish restaurant. Enjoyed a late lunch that was excellent! The dishes were perfectly prepared -- crispy cod sliders for my wife and steamed salmon, shrimp, and scallops served with steamed...More
This year we didn't have time to make dinner for thanksgiving so for the first time we went to "FEAST to GO" delicious! This was there first year for this too and we didn't know that till I picked up. Well I would do it...More
First off the restaurant looks like it should be situated on the eastern shore somewhere. Great ambiance for an enjoyable dinner. We had lobster bisque and it was hearty with a good amount of lobster. Also had the gumbo which our server said is a...More
I’ve never had a bad meal at Columbus Fish Market and there’s something to be said for that. This last meal was good not outstanding. Service is excellent, environment also great. I️ would go here anytime and there have been exceptional meals...so I️ would give...More