Buttermilk pie was average at best. Did not seem fresh. Not worth $4.50 for a slice. Clean dining area.
1 - 10 of 189 reviews
We took a break from shopping on the historic town square to check out Pie Peddlers as it had been recommended by many. Thankfully they have small size portions of their great pies. A wide variety of options of scratch made pies, all with a...More
I had the blackberry and my husband had coconut cream. They were both delicious. It’s a quaint storefront shop on the town square. Then we shopped next door. Such a pleasant afternoon.
We stopped in on National Pi Day around 10:30. Every one of us tried something different and all you could hear was the yum's from each of us as we took a bite. The different berry pies were good (be sure to try it a...More
When we stopped by this place, there were only few pies available. My first impression was "ugly pies". Then we asked them if they have Dutch Apple pies, and it turned out the owner/baker did not even know that the Dutch Apple and Apple pies...More
You will pay big city prices for a small piece of pie. And it’s only open until 6pm. We would frequent this place more if we could go after dinner but it’s never open late.
we tried a couple of slices and hands down our favorite was the caramel coconut. definitely something I've never had anywhere else and it was very good. I'd suggest ordering ahead of time if you want a whole pie to make sure your favorite is...More
Tried both fruit and pecan pies. one of the best (but not *the* best) pecan pies I've ever had. The fruit pies were absolutely fantastic (especially since you get almost twice as much of the crust as a pecan pie, and it was excellent crust).