Love this little gem...they serve fresh, original and tasty sandwiches and soups. They're carry-out only, FYI. Three cheers to Poseidon Pantry not just for good food but also for staying open in the off season!
1 - 10 of 282 reviews
The people at Pony Tails suggested we stop here to try their newest sandwich, a Thanksgiving Sub so we did. This sub came on a crunchy sour dough hoagie roll and was filled with turkey, cranberry sauce, stuffing, potato sticks, green beans and gravy. Now...More
This is a grocery and deli with no seating. We stopped to get sandwiches to take back to our motel. We appreciated the time taken to answer questions about some of the ingredients that were unfamiliar to us. There were only two staff members and...More
We spent the week at Chincoteague and could’ve eaten here for lunch every day. First, make sure you get the potato salad. It is AMAZING. I tried the Quorn Ruben and the VLT and they were both super tasty. If you need vegetarian patties or...More
Tried several restaurants in Chincoteaque but were unimpressed (lots of fried stuff and big portions but no style) so did more takeout and cooking. We ended up going to Poseidons the most. Great sandwiches and selection of craft beer, snacks and wine. Also the basics...More
I have a gluten allergy, so I tend to go there for specialty items. Decent prices considering this is the only place to get these items. Also their bacon, sliced turkey, and pimento cheese spread are all AMAZING. The spicy version of the spread is...More
Dropped in to pick up some snacks to keep at my hotel. There's a small parking lot by the side of the store. This place is a small artisanal market with an interesting assortment of mostly non-perishable food items, but there's also a small fridge...More
I called this place a week or so prior to our arrival to the island, requesting a Mediterranean themed platter to take to our hotel when we passed through. The selection of cheeses, meats, breads and fruit was perfect. The wine selection was minimal, but...More
Lots of fresh items and the sandwiches are also very good, and made while you wait. You will be amazed at some of the food items you can buy here.