I was traveling from Pittsburgh back down south, and stopped in here. It’s a very cool little place, and has a cool atmosphere with live music just upstairs!
1 - 10 of 528 reviews
One of my favorite places for quite some time now.... It's probably a toss up between SSS and Pies&Pints as to which is my favorite restaurant in WV. Both are incredible... And LOCAL! I've been coming to SSS since around 2011, and it always delivers....More
So glad to find this fun place in an area we expected to be stuck in a chain. Traveling through town, not far off highway at all. Creative sandwich selections, gluten free bread available. Can’t go wrong with any, I’d think. Also happy to find...More
I stopped by after just moving to Fayetteville in hopes to get a quick bite to eat. The food was better than a lot I have ever had. I could tell everything was amazing quality and knowledgeably prepared, I also had the cutest and sweetest...More
We needed to have a lunch while on a long day's drive and stumbled on this place. Must be the funkiest place within a few hundred miles, surely! What immense luck! It's quite small and cosy and the menu is full of interesting sandwiches and...More
When it comes to the highlights of a road trip from Toronto to Florida, it's hard to beat a stop at the Secret Sandwich Society in Fayetteville, West Virginia. The 3-day pickles are insanely delicious and worth the stop all on their own. Add in...More
We dropped in for dinner. All the sandwiches were great. The burger was excellent. Of special note, one of our crew requires gluten free and he said that it was the best gluten free bread he had ever had on a sandwich. Definitely worth the...More
After a long day of hiking we grabbed a burger and appetizers to go. Wait was minimal even though the place seemed packed, as usual! Had the pimento cheese fries, chips and dip, and the velvet... awesome! Have been there before for dine in service...More
Great sandwichs and cold local beer. I usually order the Lincoln which is a kind of build your own sandwich. Homemade chips are awesome. Must stop in Fayetteville.