Four couples visited Sidney's last night all having excellent service and fine food. I highly recommend the restaurant!
11 - 20 of 190 reviews
Love the food and ONE waitress but never made to feel welcome by host/hostess. Last month we arrived 45 minutes before closing and host had to check if kitchen was still open. Tonight hostess said that in TWO minutes they are not taking walk-ins, not...More
My wife and I had lunch at Sidney Willoughby Run yesterday with friends that live in Gettysburg and it was an absolutely amazing meal! My wife had the "Warm Seasonal Quiche" and I had the "Beer Battered Atlantic Cod". Both meals were the Best of...More
The food is the biggest draw, though the service and surroundings are exemplary as well. No breakfast, but both lunch and dinner are consistently excellent. Located just west of town on highway 30.
Just a quick drive from our hotel, the Federal Point Inn. Fresh, local ingredients - delicious small plates. We loved the summer sweet corn soup special, tuna tartare and the mac and cheese with crab meat. Comfortable setting.
We went here for an anniversary dinner, arriving much later than our reservation but we were accommodated with good will. It's a bit pricey but well worth the cost for the fantastic food and wine. We especially recommend the oysters.
The chef is superb. We chose from Appetizers , small plates, entrees, casual fare and deserts and nothing disappointed . My husband said the chicken was the best chicken he has ever had ( and he's had a lot ). The soft shell crab tempura...More
Dear Prz4711, Thank you for your generous feedback! We are greatly pleased that you enjoyed your visit and hope to see you again! Safe Travels! Very Best Regards, Sidney Willoughby Run Management
We were uncertain of what we would find at this restaurant due to its mixed reviews and the fact that they do not accept American Express as do most top tier establishments. Well, we're we favorably impressed. The location is the former Gettysburg Country Club...More
Dear Briaipatcher, Thank you for your 5 star review! We are happy to know you were pleasantly satisfied despite any hesitance. Our signature quiches tend to be our most popular lunch selection, we glad you enjoyed it! We hope to see you during any future...More
Been wanting to try this place for over a year & finally found a good excuse to splurge. I was so pleased to find the atmosphere wasn't nearly as stuffy as I expected. I love fine dining food without feeling like I should have rented...More
Dear GypsyGeorgia, Thank you so much for a great review! We are so glad you finally made it out and of course, can not wait for you to visit us again! We will keep the "pretty little gifts" coming just for you! Very Best Regards,...More