Just came back from here with my family and we left so disappointed yet it could have been so different! The young lady that served us was clearly new, I don't have an issue with this, everyone has to start somewhere and we were more...than happy to pass off the fact that the starter we ordered never came out! The other lady that brought us the pizzas asked if that was it once she had put down all 4 pizzas, it wasn't as we'd also ordered a side of garlic bread which clearly hadn't been ordered either as we had to wait a good 5mins for it until they eventually brought it to our table. This is where it really went downhill! They took our plates and then nothing, waited and waited, made eye contact with the two ladies that had been serving us but still nothing. In the end, and because my kids were annoying me about wanting to order a dessert, I eventually asked one for the dessert menu. Ordered a Nutella pizza with cream and marshmallows, again, waited what seemed like an eternity for it and I even looked over at the kitchen area and I could see a pizza on the side under a heat lamp but assumed/hoped it wasn't ours as it had been sat there for ages and with cream on top I knew it wasn't going to be good if it was ours! Unfortunately for us, and them, it was our pizza so when she brought it to us all the cream had started to congeal as it had been sat there under a heat lamp for so long. Also didn't have marshmallows on so asked about this and they apologised and said they'd run out! Decided to give it a go and it was barely luke warm so told them to take it back and give us the bill. Even when they brought the bill out it had the dessert on so had to ask them to amend this too! All in all it was such a disappointing end to what started so well as the pizzas were truly amazing, gutted!More

What a fabulous find . Top quality cooking using locally sourced ingredients . Could have ordered the entire menu but settled on 3 courses , plus we ordered the steak to share as the food was soo good . Really genuine family run business -...travelled from Brighton and will definitely come backMore

As a regular customer and totally aware of the policy of no bookings and walk ins only. On the visit tonight to celebrate an occasion with the family we were informed that all tables were full and we would have to wait, and a family...of 4 were in front on the waiting list. This was totally fine and we were in the process of ordering drinks. What occurred next was very sneaky, in fact rude!!! A further family of 4 entered into the restaurant who it became quite clear were friends/family of the staff. To our amazement and disappointment, the friends/family were fast tracked in front of both ourselves and the other family waiting, going against their own policy. The female bar staff knew and when questioned were embarrassed. The male bar staff said "they're friends mate sorry". Upon hearing this statement we left! Shocking customer service!!! Unfortunately and out of principle, we will never return, which disappoints us as we have had many good experiences in there.More

Great food, service and friendly staff. Lovely atmosphere. Delicious stone baked pizzas. Would highly recommend a visit.

Went to this place based on previous reviews, and it didn't disappoint. Great service and even greater pizza. Good choice of pizzas and specials. Deceptively bigger than you'd think, so even on a warm weekend, we managed to get a lunchtime table. Would definitely recommend...and return.More

This was our third visit to No 23 but the first time with all three grown up kids and one grandkid. We ordered the Garlic Bites, Cheesey Garlic Bread and Padron Peppers for starters. Then a selection of pizzas including a vegan pizza. We enjoyed...absolutely everything so thank you to Louis and Scott who were working the kitchen. To Mark and Alex who made us feel very welcome from the minute we arrived, and the rest of the team who looked after us. Our family dog was also welcomed and was cosy on the dog bed throughout which enabled us to relax and enjoy ourselves. The pizzas are so good and that’s partly due to the quality of the home made dough and the sauce. We all brought some pizza home as we couldn’t eat it all. I popped mine in the air fryer for three minutes and it was perfect. We will be back!More

Amazing food and the service was really exceptional. Brilliant friendly team on a busy Saturday night, but they found us a table and served us really quickly.🙌🙌

Lucy was excellent and super friendly!!!! Amazing and fast service all night. Would recommend to a friend!

Lucy served us tonight she was very professional and attentive gorgeous pizza as usual made by Scott best pizza iv ever had will definatly be back

Lovely set up this. The staff were all extremely friendly and helpful, great with our two kids. The beer on tap was varied and the two I had were great. Pizzas were brilliant, although the generous sized starters meant I took half home for 2nds...later that evening. Would thoroughly recommend this place.More

I'm a man who's eaten many a pizza, from the hills of Tuscany to the kebab shops of Edinburgh, and I think that every pizza has its place. I also thought that with this in mind, pizza had lost its ability to surprise me. I...was wrong. Number Twenty-Three, somehow, gave me a totally new experience in pizza. I don't know what they did, or how they made it, but they provided me with possibly the best pizza I've had in my whole life, so good in fact that I would consider driving the length of the country to Saltburn just so I could have another one. And all this amongst a great and relaxed setting with copious beers available, and with excellent service provided by the lovely Ella. So if you find yourself in Saltburn, just go there.More

Recently whilst on holiday in Saltburn we enjoyed two meals at No 23. We had delicious, starters, pizzas and desserts. There was a printed menu and a specials board so a great choice on offer. The bar also had a fantastic selection of drinks from...cocktails through to specialty beers and ciders. The staff were very friendly and professional but special thanks go to Alex and Lucy who went out of their way to make our visits memorable. Would thoroughly recommend No23 as a great place to meet and dine.More