We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
The latest reviews. The lowest prices. The perfect place to shop for hotels.

Restaurants in Shelter Island

View map
Map
Satellite
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
Updating Map...
Reservations
Online Bookings
Cuisines & Dishes
(31)
(15)
(4)
Bar
(22)
(14)
Central American
(1)
Contemporary
(2)
Diner
(6)
(4)
(1)
(2)
Grill
(1)
(2)
(8)
Pub
(16)
(5)
Southwestern
(1)
(3)
Baguette
(2)
Burrito
(1)
Ceviche
(1)
Chowder
(1)
Crab
(7)
Dumplings
(1)
Fish & Chips
(4)
Gyros
(1)
Hamburger
(4)
Lobster
(15)
Lobster Roll
(10)
Omelette
(3)
Oyster
(9)
Pasta
(1)
Polenta
(2)
Ribs
(2)
Sandwiches
(2)
Shrimp
(12)
Tapas
(1)
Tortillas
(1)
More
Dietary Restrictions
Gluten Free Options
(15)
Vegetarian Friendly
(11)
Vegan Options
(3)
Meals
Price
Cheap Eats
(33)
Mid-range
(150)
Fine Dining
(11)
Restaurant features
Free Wifi
(19)
Parking Available
(24)
Reservations
(50)
Serves Alcohol
(60)
Takeout
(69)
Television
(20)
Wheelchair Accessible
(55)
More
Good for
Bar Scene
(27)
(19)
Kids
(30)
Local cuisine
(15)
More
18 Bay
££££
Shelter Island
Vine Street Cafe
££££, American
Shelter Island
The Frisky Oyster
££££, American, Seafood, International
Greenport 2.4 mi away
Rams Head Inn Restaurant
££££, American
Shelter Island
Stars Cafe
£, American, Cafe
Shelter Island
Sterlington Deli
£, American, Delicatessen
Greenport 2.5 mi away
The Islander
£, American, Diner
Shelter Island
Shelter Island Craft Brewery
£, Bar, Pub
Shelter Island
Italian (15)
Pizza (7)
Mexican (7)
Seafood (31)
American (67)
Delicatessen (8)
Bar (23)
Pub (16)
18 Bay
££££
Shelter Island
Find a table
Vine Street Cafe
££££, American
Shelter Island
Find a table
The Tavern at Shelter Island House
££ - £££, American, Grill, Bar
Shelter Island
Find a table
Noah's
££ - £££, American, Seafood
Greenport 2.5 mi away
Find a table
Reddings Market
££ - £££, American, Cafe, Delicatessen
Shelter Island
Stars Cafe
£, American, Cafe
Shelter Island
Sterlington Deli
£, American, Delicatessen
Greenport 2.5 mi away
Sunset Beach
££ - £££, French, American, Bar
Shelter Island
Sort by:
  • Ranking
  • Name
We found great results, but some are outside Shelter Island. Showing results within 25 mi of Shelter Island.
Limit search to Shelter Island.

18 Bay

#1 of 23 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Reserve

Vine Street Cafe

#2 of 23 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Reserve

Lucharito's Greenport, NY 2.4 mi away

#1 of 44 Restaurants in Greenport

Salt

#3 of 23 Restaurants in Shelter Island
££ - £££ American Seafood Bar

The Frisky Oyster Greenport, NY 2.4 mi away

#2 of 44 Restaurants in Greenport

Reddings Market Shelter Island Heights

#1 of 1 Bakeries in Shelter Island
££ - £££ American Cafe Delicatessen

Stars Cafe

#4 of 23 Restaurants in Shelter Island

Sterlington Deli Greenport, NY 2.5 mi away

#3 of 44 Restaurants in Greenport

Rams Head Inn Restaurant Shelter Island Heights

#5 of 23 Restaurants in Shelter Island
££££ American

Sweet Tomato's Shelter Island Heights

#6 of 23 Restaurants in Shelter Island
££ - £££ Italian

The Islander

#7 of 23 Restaurants in Shelter Island
£ American Diner

The Tavern at Shelter Island House

#8 of 23 Restaurants in Shelter Island
££ - £££ American Grill Bar Seafood Pub
Reserve

Maria's kitchen

#9 of 23 Restaurants in Shelter Island
££ - £££ Mexican

Sunset Beach Shelter Island Heights

#10 of 23 Restaurants in Shelter Island
££ - £££ French American Bar Seafood Pub

Kyle's

#11 of 23 Restaurants in Shelter Island
££ - £££ American

Commander Cody's

#12 of 23 Restaurants in Shelter Island
££ - £££ American Seafood

Red Maple

#13 of 23 Restaurants in Shelter Island
££ - £££ American Bar Seafood Contemporary

Noah's Greenport, NY 2.5 mi away

#4 of 44 Restaurants in Greenport
Reserve

Shelter Island Heights Pharmacy Shelter Island Heights

#14 of 23 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Diner

Southold Fish Market Southold, NY 3.0 mi away

#2 of 27 Restaurants in Southold
££ - £££ American Seafood Soups

Shelter Island Craft Brewery

#15 of 23 Restaurants in Shelter Island
£ Bar Pub

Salamander's On Front Greenport, NY 2.5 mi away

#5 of 44 Restaurants in Greenport
££ - £££ American

The Pridwin Restaurant

#16 of 23 Restaurants in Shelter Island
££ - £££ Seafood American

Little Creek Oyster Farm & Market Greenport, NY 2.4 mi away

#8 of 44 Restaurants in Greenport
££ - £££ American Seafood

American Beech Greenport, NY 2.5 mi away

#6 of 44 Restaurants in Greenport
Reserve

Tuck Shop Shelter Island Heights

#1 of 1 Dessert in Shelter Island

1943 Pizza Bar Greenport, NY 2.6 mi away

#7 of 44 Restaurants in Greenport
££ - £££ Italian Pizza

Hellenic Snack Bar & Restaurant East Marion, NY 3.5 mi away

#1 of 3 Restaurants in East Marion

Claudio's Restaurant Greenport, NY 2.4 mi away

#11 of 44 Restaurants in Greenport
££ - £££ American Seafood Soups

Eagle Deli

#17 of 23 Restaurants in Shelter Island