I'll admit, this is a tad embarrassing. I'm a regular poster here but can't remember some suggestions for a quick, simple, less expensive stay. We usually go up in October for our anniversary and prefer 2BR/2BA condos with extra amenities. This time, we're not sure if we'll just come for the day or spend one night. So in order to cut the budget a bit, I'm looking for something simple. I also figure this will be a good place to help others who have the same question.
I remember that the Lull-Abi in Egg Harbor has been suggested and gets terrific reviews, we were very happy with the Somerset in Ephraim and may consider them. The plus there is both the indoor and outdoor pool. Others have suggested Main Street in Fish Creek. For a small suite Homestead seems nice (and have always been very friendly on the phone) but we're fine with something smaller for just one night.
Oh and don't even THINK of suggesting camping! I'm a Frozen Gal, NOT a Camping Gal--hiking yes, sleeping in a tent, no way!