After all the help you all have given me I thought I made up my mind. I showed my husband some pictures online of Shoal Bay East, Meads Bay & Rendezvous Bay and while he thought they all were pretty he said he would really prefer a small cozy beach. Can anyone recommend a small beach on Anguilla that we can take a taxi to when we get off the ferry? We will spend the day there. Not sure if we will be able to rent chairs, but it seems like this will be more appealing to him and this is an anniversary gift to him so I want to make it special. Thanks!